Motaleb began his Dhaka League career with Rahmatganj MFS in 1969. He participated in India's Bordoloi Trophy with the club in 1973 and was also a member of the team that finished runners-up in both the league and Liberation Cup in 1977. Motaleb won Sher-e-Bangla Cup with the Dhaka District three consecutive times from 1973 to 1975.[3]
In 1982, Motaleb joined Abahani Krira Chakra and in the same year scored in the tie-breaker against Team BJMC in the Federation Cup semi-final. Motaleb went on to win the league title with Abahani for three consecutive seasons from 1983 to 1985.[4] He also participated in the 1985–86 Asian Club Championship with the club.[5]
On 13 August 1973, following the tournament's conclusion, Bangladesh played a friendly against Singapore, and defeated the hosts 1–0 to secure the nations first ever victory in international football. During the game, Motaleb saved a penalty from Singapore, and also recorded the country's first ever cleansheet in international football.[5]
In 1975, Motaleb participated in the 1975 AFC Youth Championship and also represented the senior team during its second time participating in the Merdeka Cup. An aging Motaleb was made captain of the national team for the 1982 Asian Games; however, after making consecutive blunders which led to goals in the tournament's opening game against India, he was replaced by teenage goalkeeper, Mohamed Mohsin for the rest of the games.[3]
On 24 January 2008, Motaleb participated in an exhibition football match between former star footballers of India and Bangladesh at the Bangabandhu National Stadium.[11]
Alam, Masud (2017). ফুটবলের গল্প ফুটবলারদের গল্প (transl. The story of football the story of footballers) (in Bengali). Bishhoshahitto Bhobon. ISBN9789849134688.
Dulal, Mahmud (2020). খেলার মাঠে মুক্তিযুদ্ধ (transl. Liberation war in the playground) (in Bengali). Bishhoshahitto Bhobon. ISBN978-984-8218-31-0.