Antitheism

Antitheism, also spelled anti-theism, is the philosophical position that theism should be opposed.^[1]^[2] The term has had a range of applications. In secular contexts, it typically refers to direct opposition to the belief in any deity.

Etymology

The word antitheism (or hyphenated anti-theism) has been recorded in English since 1788.^[3] The etymological roots of the word are the Greek anti and theos.

The Oxford English Dictionary defines antitheist as "One opposed to belief in the existence of a god". The earliest citation given for this meaning dates from 1833.^[4]^[2] The term was likely coined by Pierre-Joseph Proudhon.^[5]

Opposition to theism

Antitheism has been adopted as a label by those who regard theism as dangerous, destructive, or encouraging of harmful behavior. Christopher Hitchens (2001)^[6] wrote:

"I'm not even an atheist so much as I am an antitheist; I not only maintain that all religions are versions of the same untruth, but I hold that the influence of churches, and the effect of religious belief, is positively harmful."^[6]

Opposition to the idea of God

Other definitions of antitheism include that of the French Catholic philosopher Jacques Maritain (1953), for whom it is "an active struggle against everything that reminds us of God".^[7]

The definition of Robert Flint (1877), Professor of Divinity at the University of Edinburgh was similar. Flint's 1877 Baird Lecture was titled Anti-Theistic Theories.^[8] He used "antitheism" as a very general umbrella term for all opposition to his own form of theism, which he defined as

the "belief that the heavens and the earth and all that they contain owe their existence and continuance to the wisdom and will of a supreme, self-existent, omnipotent, omniscient, righteous, and benevolent Being, who is distinct from, and independent of, what He has created."^[8]^(p 1)

Flint wrote^[8]

"In dealing with theories which have nothing in common except that they are antagonistic to theism, it is necessary to have a general term to designate them. Anti-theism appears to be the appropriate word. It is, of course, much more comprehensive in meaning than the term atheism. It applies to all systems which are opposed to theism. It includes, therefore, atheism, but short of atheism, there are anti-theistic theories."

"Polytheism is not atheism, for it does not deny that there is a deity; but it is anti-theistic since it denies that there is only one. Pantheism is not atheism, for it asserts that there is a god; but it is anti-theism, for it denies that God is a being distinct from creation and possessed of such attributes as wisdom, and holiness, and love. Every theory which refuses to ascribe to a god an attribute which is essential to a worthy conception of its character is anti-theistic. Only those theories which refuse to acknowledge that there is evidence even for the existence of a god are atheistic."^[8]^(p 23)

However, Flint also acknowledged that antitheism is typically understood differently from how he defines it. In particular, he notes that it has been used as a subdivision of atheism, descriptive of the view that theism has been disproven, rather than as the more general term that Flint preferred. He rejected the alternative non-theistic

"not merely because of its hybrid origin and character, but also because it is far too comprehensive. The theories of physical and mental science are non-theistic, even when in no degree, directly or indirectly, antagonistic to theism."^[8]^{(p 444–445)}

Other, similar terms

Opposition to the existence of a god or gods is frequently referred to as nontheism, or dystheism, or misotheism.

Dystheism would actually mean "belief in a deity that is not benevolent".
Misotheism, strictly speaking, means "hatred of God".

Examples of belief systems founded on the principle of opposition to the existence of a god or gods include some forms of Atheistic Satanism and maltheism.

Different definitions of "antitheism"

Christopher New (1993)^[9] proposed an altered definition of the word antitheism as part of a thought experiment. He imagines what arguments for the existence of an evil god would look like, and writes

"Antitheists, like theists, would have believed in an omnipotent, omniscient, eternal creator; but whereas theists in fact believe that the supreme being is also perfectly good, antitheists would have believed that he was perfectly evil."^[9]^[10]

New's changed definition has reappeared in the work of W.A. Murphree.^[11]

References

^ Cline, Austin. "Atheism and anti-theism: What's the difference? What is "anti-theism"?". About.com. Archived from the original on 2013-12-19. Retrieved 2016-12-23.
^ ^a ^b "antitheism". The Free Dictionary.
^ "antitheism". Online Etymology Dictionary.
^ "antitheism". The Shorter OED (reprint ed.). 1970. p. 78.
^ Noce, Augusto Del (5 January 2022). The Problem of Atheism. McGill-Queen's Press - MQUP. ISBN 9780228009382.
^ ^a ^b Hitchens, C. (2001). "Letters to a Young Contrarian" (Book Excerpt). Archived from the original on 2009-09-15.
See also Wikipedia article Letters to a Young Contrarian
^ Maritain, J. (1953). The Range of Reason. London, UK: Geoffrey Bles. p. 104. Archived from the original on 2013-04-07.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e Flint, Robert (1894) [1877]. Anti-Theistic Theories: Being the Baird Lecture for 1877 (5th ed.). London, UK: William Blackwood and Sons.
^ ^a ^b New, C. (June 1993). "Antitheism – a reflection". Ratio. 6 (1): 36–43. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9329.1993.tb00051.x.
^ Daniels, Charles B. (June 1997). "God, demon, good, evil". The Journal of Value Inquiry. 31 (2): 177–181. doi:10.1023/A:1004275010090. S2CID 169336704.
^ Murphree, Wallace A. (March 1997). "Natural theology: Theism or antitheism". Sophia. 36 (1): 75–83. doi:10.1007/BF02786044. S2CID 170924107.

Sources

Barker, Dan (1993). "Evangelistic atheism: Leading believers astray". Freethought Today. Archived from the original on 2005-11-26. Retrieved 2005-11-26.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
Browne, Janet (2002). The Power of Place, Volume 2 of the Biography of Charles Darwin. Alfred Knopf
Hitchens, Christopher (2001). Letters to a Young Contrarian (ISBN 0-465-03032-7). New York: Basic Books.
Maritain, Jacques (1953). The Range of Reason. London: Geoffrey Bles. Electronic Text
- Note: Chapter 8, The Meaning of Contemporary Atheism (p. 103–117, Electronic Text) is reprinted from Review of Politics, Vol. 11 (3) July 1949, p. 267–280 Electronic Text. A version also appears The Listener, Vol. 43 No.1102, 9 March 1950. pp. 427–429,432.
Segal, David (26 October 2006). "Atheist evangelist". The Washington Post (article). p. C01.
Witham, Larry (2003). By Design, Encounter Books
Wolff, Gary (November 2006). "The new atheism: The church of the non-believers". Wired magazine (reprint).
Wright, N.T. (2005). The Last Word, Harper San Francisco