Anthony was a middle-order batsman, strong on the pull and the square cut, an accurate slow bowler, and a brilliant fieldsman.[2] He was the first winner of the Redpath Cup, awarded since 1920–21 to the best New Zealand batsman of the first-class season.[3] He scored 251 runs in the Plunket Shield in 1920–21 at an average of 62.75, including 55 not out and 113 in Auckland's 382-run victory over Canterbury.[4] He made his highest first-class score of 116 against Canterbury in 1929–30, when he was 43.[5] He took his best bowling figures of 6 for 43 against the touring MCC in 1922–23.[6] He played senior club cricket for Parnell in Auckland until November 1937, when he was 51.[2]