She previously served as Minister of Education under President Nicanor Duarte, and Duarte endorsed her bid for the presidency. Initial results showed Ovelar narrowly defeating her rival for the nomination, former Vice President Luis Castiglioni, in the party's primary, held in December 2007;[1] however, the result was disputed, leading to a recount.[2] On 21 January, the Colorado Party electoral commission announced that Ovelar had won with 45.04% of the vote against 44.5% for Castiglioni, although Castiglioni continued to claim victory.[3]
Not only would Ovelar have been Paraguay's first female president if elected, but she was the first woman to run for president.[3] Opposition candidate Fernando Lugo won the election, held on 20 April 2008, thereby ousting the Colorado Party after 61 years of continuous rule. Ovelar conceded the race to Lugo at about 9 PM local time on election night.[citation needed]