The speedway promotion agreed with the stock car promotion that a separate speedway track could be built adjacent to the main circuit. The team was then renamed the Buxton Hitmen from the 1996 Speedway Conference League season.[8] The first season on the new track in 1996 ended with an eighth-place finish.[9][10]
Buxton against Oxford in 2007Buxton versus Oxford in 2007
During the 2002 Speedway Conference League season the team won their first silverware when winning the Conference League Knockout Cup.[13] They comfortably defeated the Rye House Raiders 99–81 on aggregate in the final, with William Beveridge scoring a 15-point home leg maximum and Aidan Collins scoring 17 in the away leg.[14]
The remainder of the decade was spent in mid-table positions, with the highlight being the Riders' Championship successes by James Wright in 2004[15]Adam Roynon in 2006[16] and Craig Cook in 2009.[17]
The Hitmen struggled to compete in the league in the following years, finishing last in 2016 and enduring a disastrous campaign during 2018. After the 2018 season, the speedway club chairman Jayne Moss withdrew the club at the National League AGM, following financial struggles. The speedway team has not raced since.[19] In the 25 years that the team raced they always competed in the third division.
