Share to: share facebook share twitter share wa share telegram print page

Central London Property Trust Ltd v High Trees House Ltd

High Trees
High Trees House in Clapham, London
CourtKing's Bench Division
Decided18 July 1946
Citation[1947] KB 130; [1956] 1 All ER 256; 62 TLR 557; [1947] LJR 77; 175 LT 333
Transcript[1]
Court membership
Judge sittingDenning J
Keywords
Promissory estoppel

Central London Property Trust Ltd v High Trees House Ltd [1947] KB 130, commonly called High Trees, is a leading opinion in the High Court relating to contract law. It reaffirmed and extended the doctrine of promissory estoppel in the contract law of England and Wales. However, the most significant part of the judgment is obiter dictum as it relates to hypothetical facts; that is, the landlord did not seek repayment of the full wartime rent.

Denning J held estoppel to be applicable if

a promise was made which was intended to create legal relations and which, to the knowledge of the person making the promise, was going to be acted on by the person to whom it was made and which was in fact so acted on.

Facts

High Trees House Ltd leased a block of flats in Battersea, London from Central London Property Trust Ltd. The agreement was made in 1937 and specified an annual ground rent of £2,500. The outbreak of World War II in September 1939 led to a downturn in the rental market. High Trees struggled to find tenants for the property and approached Central London Property Trust in January 1940 to request that the rent be lowered. A reduction to £1,250 per year was agreed in writing, though the duration was not specified and no consideration was provided.

By 1945, the building was returning to full occupancy. On 21 September 1945, Central London Property wrote to High Trees to request a return to the full rent of £2,500 and claiming arrears of £7,916 for the period since 1940. They then brought a test action to recover part of the debt for the two quarters which had elapsed since June 1945.

Judgment

Based on previous judgments as Hughes v Metropolitan Railway Co, Denning J held that the full rent was payable from the time that the flats became fully occupied in mid-1945. However, he continued in an obiter statement that if Central London had tried to claim for the full rent from 1940 onwards, they would not have been able to. This was reasoned on the basis that if a party leads another party to believe that he will not enforce his strict legal rights, then the courts will prevent him from doing so at a later stage. Being obiter dicta and in a court of first instance this was doubly not a binding precedent, yet it essentially created the doctrine of promissory estoppel.

If I were to consider this matter without regard to recent developments in the law, there is no doubt that had the plaintiffs claimed it, they would have been entitled to recover ground rent at the rate of £2,500 a year from the beginning of the term, since the lease under which it was payable was a lease under seal which, according to the old common law, could not be varied by an agreement by parol (whether in writing or not), but only by deed. Equity, however stepped in, and said that if there has been a variation of a deed by a simple contract (which in the case of a lease required to be in writing would have to be evidenced by writing), the courts may give effect to it as is shown in Berry v. Berry [1929] 2 K. B. 316. That equitable doctrine, however, could hardly apply in the present case because the variation here might be said to have been made without consideration. With regard to estoppel, the representation made in relation to reducing the rent was not a representation of an existing fact. It was a representation, in effect, as to the future, namely, that payment of the rent would not be enforced at the full rate but only at the reduced rate. Such a representation would not give rise to an estoppel, because, as was said in Jorden v. Money (1854) 5 H. L. C. 185, a representation as to the future must be embodied as a contract or be nothing.

But what is the position in view of developments in the law in recent years? The law has not been standing still since Jorden v. Money (1854) 5 H. L. C. 185. There has been a series of decisions over the last fifty years which, although they are said to be cases of estoppel are not really such. They are cases in which a promise was made which was intended to create legal relations and which, to the knowledge of the person making the promise, was going to be acted on by the person to whom it was made and which was in fact so acted on. In such cases the courts have said that the promise must be honoured. The cases to which I particularly desire to refer are: Fenner v. Blake [1900] 1 Q. B. 426, In re Wickham (1917) 34 T. L. R. 158, Re William Porter & Co., Ld. [1937] 2 All E. R. 361 and Buttery v. Pickard [1946] W. N. 25. As I have said they are not cases of estoppel in the strict sense. They are really promises - promises intended to be binding, intended to be acted on, and in fact acted on. Jorden v. Money (1854) 5 H. L. C. 185 can be distinguished, because there the promisor made it clear that she did not intend to be legally bound, whereas in the cases to which I refer the proper inference was that the promisor did intend to be bound. In each case the court held the promise to be binding on the party making it, even though under the old common law it might be difficult to find any consideration for it. The courts have not gone so far as to give a cause of action in damages for the breach of such a promise, but they have refused to allow the party making it to act inconsistently with it. It is in that sense, and that sense only, that such a promise gives rise to an estoppel. The decisions are a natural result of the fusion of law and equity: for the cases of Hughes v. Metropolitan Ry. Co. (1877) 2 App. Cas. 439, 448, Birmingham and District Land Co. v. London & North Western Ry. Co. (1888) 40 Ch. D. 268, 286 and Salisbury (Marquess) v. Gilmore [1942] 2 K. B. 38, 51, afford a sufficient basis for saying that a party would not be allowed in equity to go back on such a promise. In my opinion, the time has now come for the validity of such a promise to be recognized. The logical consequence, no doubt is that a promise to accept a smaller sum in discharge of a larger sum, if acted upon, is binding notwithstanding the absence of consideration: and if the fusion of law and equity leads to this result, so much the better. That aspect was not considered in Foakes v. Beer (1884) 9 App. Cas. 605. At this time of day however, when law and equity have been joined together for over seventy years, principles must be reconsidered in the light of their combined effect. It is to be noticed that in the Sixth Interim Report of the Law Revision Committee, pars. 35, 40, it is recommended that such a promise as that to which I have referred should be enforceable in law even though no consideration for it has been given by the promisee. It seems to me that, to the extent I have mentioned, that result has now been achieved by the decisions of the courts.

I am satisfied that a promise such as that to which I have referred is binding and the only question remaining for my consideration is the scope of the promise in the present case. I am satisfied on all the evidence that the promise here was that the ground rent should be reduced to £1,250 a year as a temporary expedient while the block of flats was not fully, or substantially fully let, owing to the conditions prevailing. That means that the reduction in the rent applied throughout the years down to the end of 1944, but early in 1945 it is plain that the flats were fully let, and, indeed the rents received from them (many of them not being affected by the Rent Restrictions Acts), were increased beyond the figure at which it was originally contemplated that they would be let. At all events the rent from them must have been very considerable. I find that the conditions prevailing at the time when the reduction in rent was made, had completely passed away by the early months of 1945. I am satisfied that the promise was understood by all parties only to apply under the conditions prevailing at the time when it was made, namely, when the flats were only partially let, and that it did not extend any further than that. When the flats became fully let, early in 1945, the reduction ceased to apply.

In those circumstances, under the law as I hold it, it seems to me that rent is payable at the full rate for the quarters ending 29 September and 25 December 1945.

If the case had been one of estoppel, it might be said that in any event the estoppel would cease when the conditions to which the representation applied came to an end, or it also might be said that it would only come to an end on notice. In either case it is only a way of ascertaining what is the scope of the representation. I prefer to apply the principle that a promise intended to be binding, intended to be acted on and in fact acted on, is binding so far as its terms properly apply. Here it was binding as covering the period down to the early part of 1945, and as from that time full rent is payable.

I therefore give judgment for the plaintiff company for the amount claimed.

Significance

Advances have been made in promissory estoppel since its inception in High Trees to create a new inroad into the rule in Pinnel's case that an agreement to accept part payment of a debt in full satisfaction of it is unenforceable for want of consideration. Denning commented that such an agreement should now be enforceable under the doctrine of promissory estoppel, and indeed the plaintiff did not seek the full debt on the basis of what was fair and, perhaps, thought was the law. However, the courts were at first reluctant to overrule or distinguish cases like Pinnel's case and Foakes v Beer having formed part of the common law for so long. Lady Justice Arden in Collier v P & MJ Wright (Holdings) Ltd (2007)[1] accepted in principle that High Trees could be used to extinguish a creditor's right to full payment of a debt in such circumstances.

In Amalgamated Investment Co v Texas Bank[2] it was decided that proprietary estoppel can act as a sword and not merely as a shield (that is, it can be used as a cause of action rather than merely providing a defence to an action).

See also

References

  1. ^ Collier v P & MJ Wright (Holdings) Ltd [2007] EWCA Civ 1329
  2. ^ Amalgamated Investment Co v Texas Bank, [1982] EWHC 84 (QB).

Read other articles:

Untuk kegunaan lain, lihat Yang Terbaik. Yang TerbaikAlbum kompilasi karya Ruth SahanayaDirilis28 Agustus 1995Direkam1987-1995GenrePopLabelAquarius MusikindoKronologi Ruth Sahanaya Yang Terbaik (1995) Greatest Hits (2002) Singel dalam album Yang Terbaik Harus Kumiliki Yang TerbaikDirilis: Agustus 1995 Usah Kau Lara Sendiri (bersama Katon Bagaskara)Dirilis: September 1995 Greatest Hits2002 Templat:Extra album cover 2 Yang Terbaik adalah album studio Ruth Sahanaya yang dirilis pada pertengahan…

Gerrer RebbeMulai1905Berakhir3 Juni 1948PendahuluYehudah Aryeh Leib AlterPenggantiYisrael AlterPenjelasan pribadiNama lahirAvraham Mordechai AlterLahir(1865-12-25)25 Desember 1865Góra Kalwaria, PolandiaWafat3 Juni 1948(1948-06-03) (umur 82)Yerusalem, IsraelDinastiGerPasanganChaya Ruda Czarna, Feyge Mintshe BidermanAnak-anakMeir AlterYitzchak AlterFeyge AlterEsther AlterYisrael AlterSimcha Bunim Alter, Pinchas Menachem Alter Avraham Mordechai Alter (Polandia: Abraham Mordekhaj Altercode: pl…

Algoritme k tetangga terdekat (Inggris: k-nearest neighbour algorithmcode: en is deprecated , disingkat k-NN) adalah sebuah metode untuk melakukan klasifikasi terhadap objek berdasarkan data pemelajaran yang jaraknya paling dekat dengan objek tersebut. Data pemelajaran digambarkan ke ruang berdimensi banyak dengan tiap-tiap dimensi mewakili tiap ciri/fitur dari data. Klasifikasi data baru dilakukan dengan mencari label k tetangga terdekat. Label terbanyak yang muncul menjadi label data baru. Bil…

Cles commune di Italia Cles (it) Tempat categoria:Articles mancats de coordenades Negara berdaulatItaliaRegion otonom dengan status khususTrentino-Tirol SelatanProvinsi di ItaliaTrentino Ibu kota dariVal di Non (en) (2006–) NegaraItalia Ibu kotaCles PendudukTotal7.201  (2023 )GeografiLuas wilayah39,17 km² [convert: unit tak dikenal]Ketinggian656 m Berbatasan denganCagnò Caldes Cavizzana Cis Croviana Dimaro Folgarida (en) Livo Malè Novella (en) Terzolas Sanzeno Ville d'Anaunia …

Award Award The 2022 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicinefor his research in the field of genomes of extinct hominins and human evolutionDate3 October 2022 (2022-10-03)LocationStockholmCountrySwedenPresented byNobel Assembly at Karolinska InstitutetHosted byThomas PerlmannReward(s)9 million SEK (2017)[1]First awarded19012022 laureateSvante PääboWebsite2022 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine ← 2021 · Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine · 2023&…

And & EndAlbum mini karya T-araDirilis11 September 2014Direkam2014Genre K-pop EDM ballad BahasaKoreaLabelCore Contents Media, KT MusicKronologi T-ara Gossip Girls (2014)Gossip Girls2014 And & End (2014) So Good (2015)So Good2015 Singel dalam album And & End Sugar Free (Versi BigRoom)Dirilis: 10 September 2014 Sugar FreeDirilis: 11 September 2014 And & End (ditulis sebagai AND&END) adalah album mini keenam [A] dari grup vokal wanita asal Korea Selatan T-ara, yang d…

DendengRincianJenisdried meat (en) lbs Dendeng. Dendeng sapi. Dendeng sapi sesudah digoreng. RESEP DENDENG SAPI KERING Dendeng adalah daging yang dipotong tipis menjadi serpihan yang lemaknya dipangkas, dibumbui dengan saus asam, asin atau manis dengan dikeringkan dengan api kecil atau diasinkan dan dijemur. Hasilnya adalah daging yang asin dan setengah manis dan tidak perlu disimpan di lemari es. Dendeng adalah contoh makanan yang diawetkan. Pembuatan Resep dendeng biasanya menggunakan satu jen…

Voce principale: Forlì Football Club. Calcio ForlìStagione 1985-1986Sport calcio Squadra Forlì Allenatore Giancarlo Magrini Presidente Tiziano Tampellini Serie C211º posto nel girone C. Coppa ItaliaPrimo turno Maggiori presenzeCampionato: Piraccini, Tondi (33) Miglior marcatoreCampionato: Di Chio (8) StadioStadio Tullo Morgagni 1984-1985 1986-1987 Si invita a seguire il modello di voce Questa pagina raccoglie le informazioni riguardanti il Calcio Forlì nelle competizioni ufficiali dell…

Eka PutraS.E., M.M. Bupati Tanah Datar ke-13PetahanaMulai menjabat 26 Februari 2021PresidenJoko WidodoGubernurMahyeldi AnsharullahWakilRichi AprianPendahuluZuldafri DarmaPenggantiPetahana Informasi pribadiLahir11 Juli 1975 (umur 48)Tanjung Bonai, Lintau Buo Utara, Tanah Datar, Sumatera BaratKebangsaan IndonesiaPartai politikPartai DemokratSuami/istriLise VebrianaAnak3Orang tuaZainal Dt. Rajo (ayah)Alma materPolimarim AMI Veteran MakassarSTIM LPI MakassarSTIE AMKOP MakassarProfe…

82 BC conflict in Sulla's Second Civil War Battle of SacriportusPart of Sulla's Second Civil WarMarius the Younger fleeing from PrenesteDateApril, 82 BCLocationSacriporto, ItaliaResult Optimate VictoryBelligerents Optimates (Sullan Faction) Populares (Cinna-Marius Faction)Commanders and leaders Lucius Cornelius Sulla Felix Gaius Marius the YoungerStrength 40,000 Legionaries 45,000 LegionariesCasualties and losses Low ~15,000 Killed vteRoman Republican civil wars 1st Servile 2nd Servile Social Be…

Highly vulcanized rubber that is generically known as hard rubber This article is about the type of rubber. For the bowling-ball manufacturer, see Ebonite International. Ebonite applications from the 19th century Ebonite is a brand name for a material generically known as hard rubber, obtained via vulcanizing natural rubber for prolonged periods. Ebonite may contain from 25% to 80% sulfur and linseed oil.[1][2] Its name comes from its intended use as an artificial substitute for …

1969 nationwide activism against the US involvement in the Vietnam War Moratorium to End the War in VietnamPart of the opposition to the Vietnam WarLocationUnited States and AustraliaGoalsCreate peaceful mass action to end American involvement in the Vietnam WarResulted in Richard Nixon's Silent majority speech Growing protest movement vteOpposition to United Statesinvolvement in the Vietnam War Edmonton aircraft bombing March Against the Vietnam War Human Be-In Angry Arts week March on the Pent…

Football match1996 Intercontinental CupMatch programme cover Juventus River Plate 1 0 Date26 November 1996VenueNational Stadium, TokyoMan of the MatchAlessandro Del Piero (Juventus)RefereeMárcio Rezende de Freitas (Brazil)Attendance48,305← 1995 1997 → The 1996 Intercontinental Cup was an association football match played on 26 November 1996, between Juventus, winners of the 1995–96 UEFA Champions League, and River Plate, winners of the 1996 Copa Libertadores. The match was played …

1887 investigation of the speed of light For interference experiments on matter, see Hughes–Drever experiment. Michelson and Morley's interferometric setup, mounted on a stone slab that floats in an annular trough of mercury PhysicsMass–energy equivalence History of physics Branches Classical mechanics Electromagnetism Quantum mechanics Relativity Statistical mechanics Thermodynamics Research fields Applied physics Astrophysics Atomic, molecular, and optical physics Biophysics Condensed matt…

Elezioni costituenti in Cile del 2021 Stato  Cile Data 15 - 16 maggio Assemblea Convenzione costituzionale Affluenza 43,43% Liste Vamos por Chile Apruebo Dignidad La Lista del Pueblo Voti 1.174.50220,56% 1.070.36118,74% 927.60316,24% Seggi 37 / 138 28 / 138 26 / 138 Distribuzione del voto per regione — 2023 Le elezioni della Convenzione costituzionale in Cile del 2021 si sono tenute il 15 e 16 maggio. Poiché il progetto di legge costituzionale redatto è stato rifiutato in un referendum,…

Військово-музичне управління Збройних сил України Тип військове формуванняЗасновано 1992Країна  Україна Емблема управління Військово-музичне управління Збройних сил України — структурний підрозділ Генерального штабу Збройних сил України призначений для плануван…

American baseball player Baseball player Rick LangfordPitcherBorn: (1952-03-20) March 20, 1952 (age 72)Farmville, Virginia, U.S.Batted: RightThrew: RightMLB debutJune 13, 1976, for the Pittsburgh PiratesLast MLB appearanceJuly 13, 1986, for the Oakland AthleticsMLB statisticsWin–loss record73–106Earned run average4.01Strikeouts671 Teams Pittsburgh Pirates (1976) Oakland Athletics (1977–1986) James Rick Langford (born March 20, 1952) is an American former …

الإله ليس عظيما (بالإنجليزية: God is Not Great)‏  معلومات الكتاب المؤلف كريستوفر هيتشنز البلد  المملكة المتحدة اللغة الانجليزية الناشر مؤسسة أتلانتك بوكس تاريخ النشر 1 مايو 2007 النوع الأدبي صحافة الرأي،  ومقالة،  ومنشور  الموضوع نقد الأديان  المواقع OCLC 416305554  تعديل…

Brenda SongLahirBrenda Julietta SongPekerjaanAktris, Penyanyi, Model, PembicaraTahun aktif1995–sekarang (aktris)2005–sekarang (penyanyi)Situs webhttp://www.brendasongsite.com Brenda Song (lahir 27 Maret 1988) adalah seorang aktris, model dan penyanyi Amerika Serikat yang membintangi film The Suite Life of Zack and Cody dan Wedy Wu:Homecoming Warrior. Ayah Brenda adalah seorang dari suku Hmong-Mien sedangkan ibunya keturunan Thai. Filmografi Film Daftar ini termasuk film bioskop maupun t…

Community area in Chicago Community area in Illinois, United StatesUptownCommunity areaCommunity Area 03 - UptownThe Sheridan Trust and Savings Bank Building, on the corner of Broadway and Lawrence since 1924, has Chicago Landmark status.Location within the city of ChicagoCoordinates: 41°58.2′N 87°39.6′W / 41.9700°N 87.6600°W / 41.9700; -87.6600CountryUnited StatesStateIllinoisCountyCookCityChicagoArea • Total2.33 sq mi (6.03 km2)Populat…

Kembali kehalaman sebelumnya