Representing the district of Bodden Town, and standing 1.82 m (5 ft 11+1⁄2 in) tall, Alexander competed as one of five finalists in Miss Cayman Islands 2010, held in George Town on 25 September 2010. She won the Best Legs award.[4] Alexander was crowned the winner of the title, gaining the right to represent the Cayman Islands in the 2010 Miss World and the 2011 Miss Universe pageants.