From the first page, Winslow establishes an uncanny authority and profound tone that belie the book’s debut status. The precision and charm of his language lure us in and soothe us ... He paints a community so tightknit and thorough it becomes easy to forget the people in it don’t exist.[5]
The Boston Globe called it a "quietly glorious novel" that "engages on a level that’s appropriately intimate."[6]The Atlanta Journal-Constitution described it as an "enchanting debut novel," writing that it is "a refreshing and arresting book that shines a light on a woman who rebels against society’s strict and unforgiving social norms, despite the costs."[7]
Winslow's second novel, Decent People, was released in 2023. The Washington Post wrote: "Watching Winslow subvert the conventions of an old literary form is half the thrill of this novel. After all, the shelf of mystery detectives is hardly crowded with 60-year-old Black women. And that’s not the only cozy convention Winslow toys with."[8]
