Don't Tell a Soul

Don't Tell a Soul
Don't Tell a Soul
Studio album by The Replacements
Released	February 1, 1989
Recorded	1988–1989
Studio	Cherokee (Hollywood)
Genre	Alternative rock
Length	38:37
Label	Sire
Producer	Matt Wallace, The Replacements
The Replacements chronology

Don't Tell a Soul is the sixth studio album by the American rock band the Replacements, released on February 1, 1989, by Sire Records.^[1]

Recording and release

Don't Tell a Soul was the first Replacements album featuring Bob "Slim" Dunlap, who replaced founding guitarist Bob Stinson in early 1987.^[2] The album was recorded at Cherokee Studios in Los Angeles and produced by Matt Wallace and the band. It was mixed by Chris Lord-Alge, who decided to give the record "a three-dimensional, radio-ready sound".^[3] However, singer and guitarist Paul Westerberg was not satisfied with the new direction, commenting: "I thought the little things I'd cut in my basement were closer to what I wanted."^[3]

Don't Tell a Soul was released on February 1, 1989 by Sire Records. The song "I'll Be You" was released as a single.^[4] This proved to be the band's only appearance on the Billboard Hot 100: the song peaked at #51 on the May 13, 1989 chart.

In 2008, the album was remastered and reissued by Rhino Entertainment with 7 additional tracks and liner notes by Peter Jesperson.^[5] In September 2019, Rhino released Dead Man's Pop, a box set featuring a remixed and resequenced version of Don't Tell a Soul (said to be closer to the band's original intentions) assembled by the album's producer, Matt Wallace, along with rarities, demos, and other unreleased tracks. It includes a two CD release of the 1989 live concert released on vinyl as The Complete Inconcerated Live.

Critical reception

Professional ratings
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	^[2]
Chicago Sun-Times	^[6]
Christgau's Record Guide	B+^[7]
Entertainment Weekly	A−^[8]
Los Angeles Times	^[9]
NME	9/10^[10]
Pitchfork	8.0/10^[5]
Rolling Stone	^[11]
The Rolling Stone Album Guide	^[12]
Spin Alternative Record Guide	4/10^[13]

Don't Tell a Soul received generally favorable reviews, with critics noting the music's more mature themes and increasing disillusionment, along with a more private outlook.^[14] Ira Robbins of Rolling Stone praised Westerberg's writing, stating that Don't Tell a Soul "is full of his sharp-tongued wordplay and idiosyncratic musical structures."^[11] In February 1990, the album was ranked at number 16 in The Village Voice's 1989 Pazz & Jop critics' poll.^[15]

The Smashing Pumpkins' James Iha named the song "Achin' to Be" to his "mixtape for dreamers," commenting, "This is great, because he's talking about a would-be artist who's trying to do bigger stuff. And it sounds like someone everyone knows. Like he or she is an artist, but nobody really takes them seriously. So he's talking about her. She danced alone in nightclubs. She's a poet, she's an artist, she's like a movie, but at the end of the song, he's like, 'I'm like that, too. I've been aching for a while and I'm aching to be.' The narrator reveals himself, like, 'I'm just like her and I don't have the courage to go up to her.' Maybe I read too much into it. [Laughs.] But that's how it reads to me."^[16]

Track listing

All tracks are written by Paul Westerberg, except where noted

No.	Title	Writer(s)	Length
1.	"Talent Show"		3:32
2.	"Back to Back"		3:22
3.	"We'll Inherit the Earth"		4:22
4.	"Achin' to Be"		3:42
5.	"They're Blind"		4:37
6.	"Anywhere's Better Than Here"		2:49
7.	"Asking Me Lies"		3:40
8.	"I'll Be You"		3:27
9.	"I Won't"		2:43
10.	"Rock 'N' Roll Ghost"		3:23
11.	"Darlin' One"	Paul Westerberg, Slim Dunlap, Chris Mars, Tommy Stinson	3:39

2008 CD reissue bonus tracks
No.	Title	Writer(s)	Length
12.	"Portland"		4:28
13.	"Wake Up"		2:13
14.	"Talent Show" (Demo Version)		2:54
15.	"We'll Inherit the Earth" (Mix 1)		4:02
16.	"Date to Church" (with Tom Waits)		3:49
17.	"We Know the Night" (Outtake)		3:28
18.	"Gudbuy t'Jane" (Outtake)	Noddy Holder, Jim Lea	4:09