Like all other Buckingham and Nicks compositions on Fleetwood Mac's 1975 eponymous album, “I'm So Afraid” was written before Buckingham joined Fleetwood Mac.[2] Buckingham wrote "I'm So Afraid" around the time he was suffering from a bout of mononucleosis.[3]Mick Fleetwood said in his 2014 autobiography that Buckingham had labored over the song for four years and had gotten "the harmony of the guitar parts so in tune they were a virtual orchestra unto themselves."[1] Buckingham incorporated musical themes from church music on "I'm So Afraid" and built the song's chord progression around a series of triads.[2]
"I'm So Afraid" is the final track of the album, and was released as the B-side to the song "Over My Head". It is a hard rock song, atypical of Fleetwood Mac's songs (at least following the Peter Green era), but it quickly became a live staple showcasing Lindsey Buckingham's guitar skills.[4] The studio version of the song is in Gnatural minor, but live versions are usually transposed down to Fnatural minor.[5]
In his book Making Rumours, producer Ken Caillat noted how different "I'm So Afraid" sounded during live performances. Compared to the album version, which Caillat described as "mellower with a folk rock vibe", live performances saw "I'm So Afraid" become a "faster, hard-edged song."[6] Buckingham said that performing the song live is "very taxing on a nightly basis because it's got this very long solo that I have to do every night."[7] He has played the song for solo performances, beginning with the Out of the Cradle Tour in 1992–1993.[8]
"I'm So Afraid" has generally received positive reviews from music critics. In his review of the band's 1975 self-titled album, Bud Scopa of Rolling Stone thought that the song stood out upon repeated listens.[13] In 2022, the same publication ranked the "I'm So Afraid" 34th on its list of the top 50 greatest Fleetwood Mac songs, labeling it a "paranoid blues blowout".[4]The Rolling Stone Album Guide called the song a "soulful closer".[14]
^ abFleetwood, Mick; Bozza, Anthony (October 2014). Play On: Now, Then & Fleetwood Mac. New York: Little, Brown And Company. pp. 164, 169. ISBN978-0-316-40342-9.
^ abSheffield, Christopher R. Weingarten, David Browne, Jon Dolan, Corinne Cummings, Keith Harris, Rob (11 July 2017). "Fleetwood Mac's 50 Greatest Songs [No. 34]". Rolling Stone. Retrieved 20 September 2019.{{cite magazine}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
^Stephenson, Ken (2002). What to Listen for in Rock: A Stylistic Analysis, p.89. ISBN978-0-300-09239-4.
^Caillat, Ken (2012). "Making Rumours: The Inside Story of the Classic Fleetwood Mac Album". Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. p. 186. ISBN978-1-118-21808-2.