A commercial success, the album became the first LP record to sell 1 million copies.[3] The album topped US Billboard 200 charts for fifteen weeks at different times in 1956 (eight consecutive weeks), 1957, 1958, and 1959.[1]
After the musical transferred to London in April 1958, the album spent 19 consecutive weeks atop the UK charts, the biggest-selling album of the year.[4] The musical's renewed success sent Andrews, Harrison, and the London cast to the recording studio in 1959 to capture the score in stereo: the London cast recording shares all the same principals as the Broadway cast.
Columbia first released the Broadway album on compact disc in 1988, followed by numerous subsequent reissues.[5][deprecated source] As of 2023[update], the original cast recording remains among the longest-charting albums in the U.S., with 480 weeks on the Billboard 200.[6]