Share to: share facebook share twitter share wa share telegram print page

On the Malice of Herodotus

Bust of Plutarch at Chaeronea

On the Malice of Herodotus or On the Malignity of Herodotus (Greek: Περὶ τῆς Ἡροδότου κακοηθείας) is an essay by Plutarch criticizing the historian Herodotus for all manner of prejudice and misrepresentation in the latter's Histories. It has been called "the first book review"[1] and, more tellingly, "the first instance in literature of the slashing review."[2] The 19th-century English historian George Grote considered this essay a serious attack upon the works of Herodotus, and contrasts Herodotus's journalistic openness to events ("the honourable frankness which Plutarch calls his 'malignity'") to Plutarch's preferred idealizing and moralizing tone.[3]

Authenticity and reception

The tone of the essay is so waspish that many scholars (Grote was one[4]) doubted that the text was the product of the famously mild-tempered philosopher. In the 19th century in particular On the Malice was dismissed as the work of a Pseudo-Plutarch, "full of the most futile accusations of every kind".[5] in which the author merely establishes his own malignity.[6] Other critics regarded it as a school exercise by a young Plutarch who had not yet grown into his mature persona.[7] However, most modern scholars regard the work as genuine, since Plutarch demonstrated similarly strident criticisms, for example, in his attacks on Colotes.[8]

On The Malice can be seen as a rhetorical exercise, in which Plutarch plays devil's advocate to see what could be said against such a respected and well-known writer.[9] For others, the work is one of hyper-patriotism: to Plutarch scholar R. H. Barrow, for example, Plutarch sees "malignity" in Herodotus's willingness to criticize some Greek states and the respect he affords the Persians. "Plutarch," he concluded, "is fanatically biased in favor of the Greek cities; they can do no wrong."[10][11] Most recently the text has been seen as an expression of Plutarch's Platonism. He criticizes Herodotus in terms similar to those which Plato levied against Homer: his stories, though charming and well-told, are insufficiently edifying.[8]

Finally there is the element of wounded regional pride. For the proud Boeotian Plutarch, Herodotus's hostile portrayal of Thebes's role in the Persian Wars justified a harsh critique. As Plutarch himself put it:

Since he principally exerts his malice against the Boeotians and Corinthians, though without sparing any other, I think myself obliged to defend our ancestors and the truth against this part of his writings

— Plutarch, On The Malice of Herodotus, 854f

References

  1. ^ Bowen, Anthony (1992). The Malice of Herodotus. Oxford: Aris & Phillips. p. 3. ISBN 978-0856685682.
  2. ^ Kimball, Roger. "Plutarch & the issue of character". The New Criterion Online. Retrieved 2006-12-11.
  3. ^ Grote, George (2000-10-19) [1830]. A History of Greece: From the Time of Solon to 403 BC. Routledge. p. 203.
  4. ^ See Grote's footnote to the quotation above: "Plutarch - if indeed the treatise De Herodoti Malignitate be the work of Plutarch -" treats Herodotus as uncandid, malicious, corrupt, the calumniator of great men and glorious deeds"
  5. ^ William Smith, A New Classical Dictionary, Harper and Brothers (1851) page 366 digitalized version
  6. ^ A. D.Godley, Herodotus, Loeb Classical Library (1920), page xiv digitalized version
  7. ^ Moderator (1) (2016-03-15). "Plutarch's "On the Malice of Herodotus"". The Kosmos Society. Retrieved 2023-01-16.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  8. ^ a b Hershbell, Jackson (1993). "Plutarch and Herodotus: The Beetle in the Rose" (PDF). Rheinisches Museum. 136: 143–163.
  9. ^ Aubrey Stewart, George Long. "Life of Plutarch". Plutarch's Lives, Volume I (of 4). The Gutenberg Project. Retrieved 2007-01-03.
  10. ^ Barrow, R. H. (1979) [1967]. Plutarch and His Times.
  11. ^ Plutarch invented the word φιλοβάρβαρος, "lover of barbarians" for Herodotus (in On The Malice, 857a)

Read other articles:

MississippiNegara bagian BenderaLambangPeta Amerika Serikat dengan ditandaiNegaraAmerika SerikatSebelum menjadi negara bagianMississippi TerritoryBergabung ke Serikat10 Desember 1817 (20)Kota terbesarJacksonPemerintahan • GubernurTate Reeves (R) • Majelis tinggi{{{Upperhouse}}} • Majelis rendah{{{Lowerhouse}}}Senator ASCindy Hyde-Smith (R)Roger Wicker (R)Delegasi DPR AS3 Demokrat, 1 Republikan (daftar)Populasi • Total2.938.618 (perk. 2.008)[1&#…

Opera by Harrison Birtwistle The CorridorOpera by Harrison BirtwistleThe composer in 2008LibrettistDavid HarsentLanguageEnglishBased onOrpheus and EurydicePremiere12 June 2009 (2009-06-12)Aldeburgh Festival The Corridor is a chamber opera composed by Harrison Birtwistle to an English language libretto by David Harsent. It premiered at the Aldeburgh Festival on 12 June 2009. The title refers to the corridor through which Orpheus and Eurydice passed as he was leading her from the un…

Artikel ini tidak memiliki referensi atau sumber tepercaya sehingga isinya tidak bisa dipastikan. Tolong bantu perbaiki artikel ini dengan menambahkan referensi yang layak. Tulisan tanpa sumber dapat dipertanyakan dan dihapus sewaktu-waktu.Cari sumber: Jay Wijayanto – berita · surat kabar · buku · cendekiawan · JSTOR Gaya atau nada penulisan artikel ini tidak mengikuti gaya dan nada penulisan ensiklopedis yang diberlakukan di Wikipedia. Bantulah memperbai…

Election 1934 United States Senate election in Massachusetts ← 1928 November 6, 1934 1940 →   Nominee David I. Walsh Robert M. Washburn Party Democratic Republican Popular vote 852,776 536,692 Percentage 59.39% 37.38% Map key Walsh:      40–50%      50–60%      60–70%      70–80%Washburn:      50–60%      6…

Peramban web atau penelusur web (bahasa Inggris: web browser) adalah peranti lunak yang berfungsi untuk menerima dan menyajikan sumber informasi dari Internet. Sebuah sumber informasi diidentifikasi dengan URI yang dapat berupa halaman web, gambar, video, atau jenis konten lainnya.[1] Peranti lunak ini juga biasa disebut sebagai perambah web atau penjelajah web. Meskipun penelusur web terutama ditujukan untuk mengakses Internet, sebuah penelusur juga dapat digunakan untuk mengakses infor…

Ancient Egyptian solar goddess Raet / Raet-TawyPtolemaic statue of Raet discovered at Medamud, on display at the Louvre Museum.Name in hieroglyphs Major cult centerMedamud, el Tod, ThebesConsortMontu Part of a series onAncient Egyptian religion Beliefs Afterlife Cosmology Duat Ma'at Mythology Index Numerology Philosophy Soul Practices Funerals Offerings: Offering formula Temples Priestess of Hathor Pyramids Deities (list)Ogdoad Amun Amunet Hauhet Heh Kauket Kek Naunet Nu Ennead Atum Geb Isis Nep…

Jalur kereta api Purwosari–BoyolaliKereta tetes tebu dari Pabrik Gula Colomadu yang terguling di Jalur KA Purwosari-BoyolaliIkhtisarJenisLintas cabangSistemJalur kereta api rel ringan Jalur trem uapStatusTidak beroperasiTerminusPurwosariBoyolaliStasiun12OperasiDibangun olehSolosche Tramweg Maatschappij Nederlands-Indische Spoorweg MaatschappijDibuka1 Mei 1908, akuisisi oleh NISM dari SoTMDitutup1 Agustus 1973PemilikPT Kereta Api Indonesia (pemilik aset jalur dan stasiun)Karakteristik lintasLin…

Disambiguazione – Das Leben Jesu rimanda qui. Se stai cercando altri significati, vedi La vita di Gesù (disambigua). La vita di GesùTitolo originaleDas Leben Jesu Prima edizione (1906) AutoreGeorg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel 1ª ed. originale1795 Generebiografia Sottogeneresaggio teologico Lingua originaletedesco ProtagonistiGesù AntagonistiSinedrio Modifica dati su Wikidata · Manuale La vita di Gesù (Das Leben Jesu) è una delle prime opere del filosofo Georg Wilhelm Friedrich H…

Nobel Fisiologi atau KedokteranDeskripsiKontribusi terkemuka dalam fisiologi atau kedokteranNegara SwediaDipersembahkan olehAkademi Ilmu Pengetahuan Kerajaan SwediaDiberikan perdana1901Situs webhttp://nobelprize.org Penghargaan Nobel Fisiologi atau Kedokteran (Inggris: Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine; Swedia dan Norwegia: Nobelpriset i fysiologi eller medicin) adalah satu dari lima Penghargaan Nobel yang diadakan atas permintaan oleh penemu dan industrialis Swedia, Alfred Nobel. P…

Dira SugandiLahirDira Julianti Sugandi29 Juli 1979 (umur 44)Bandung, Jawa Barat, IndonesiaNama lainDira SugandiPekerjaan Aktris Penyanyi Tahun aktif2005—sekarangSuami/istriElfa Zulham Warongan ​ ​(m. 2011)​Anak1Karier musikGenreJazzR&BsoulfunkInstrumen Vokal Dira Julianti Sugandi (lahir 29 Juli 1979) adalah seorang pemeran dan penyanyi Indonesia keturunan Sunda. Karier Pada umur 9 tahun, Dira memenangkan peringkat kedua dalam kompetisi meny…

Street in Stockholm, Sweden Upper section of Slottsbacken in front of the Royal Palace and the cathedral. Slottsbacken in Stockholm during the 1780s. From right to left: Stockholm Palace, Storkyrkan, Bollhuset Theatre and the Tessin Palace. Drawing, Martin Rudolf Heland. Slottsbacken (Swedish: [ˈslɔ̂tːsˌbakːɛn], Castle Slope) is a street in Gamla stan, the old town in central Stockholm, Sweden. It stretches east from the Stockholm Cathedral and the Royal Palace down to the street …

Town in the Republic of Karelia, Russia Town in Republic of Karelia, RussiaSortavala СортавалаTown[1]An aerial view of the town center of Sortavala in 2020. FlagCoat of armsLocation of Sortavala SortavalaLocation of SortavalaShow map of RussiaSortavalaSortavala (Karelia)Show map of KareliaCoordinates: 61°42′20″N 30°41′45″E / 61.70556°N 30.69583°E / 61.70556; 30.69583CountryRussiaFederal subjectRepublic of Karelia[1]First mentioned1468E…

Montmorilloncomune Montmorillon – VedutaPonte Vecchio. LocalizzazioneStato Francia Regione Nuova Aquitania Dipartimento Vienne ArrondissementMontmorillon CantoneMontmorillon AmministrazioneSindacoYves Bouloux dal 2014 TerritorioCoordinate46°26′N 0°52′E / 46.433333°N 0.866667°E46.433333; 0.866667 (Montmorillon)Coordinate: 46°26′N 0°52′E / 46.433333°N 0.866667°E46.433333; 0.866667 (Montmorillon) Altitudine82-168 m…

Sceaux 行政国 フランス地域圏 (Région) イル=ド=フランス地域圏県 (département) オー=ド=セーヌ県郡 (arrondissement) アントニー郡小郡 (canton) 小郡庁所在地INSEEコード 92071郵便番号 92330市長(任期) フィリップ・ローラン(2008年-2014年)自治体間連合 (fr) メトロポール・デュ・グラン・パリ人口動態人口 19,679人(2007年)人口密度 5466人/km2住民の呼称 Scéens地理座標 北緯48度46…

هنودمعلومات عامةنسبة التسمية الهند التعداد الكليالتعداد قرابة 1.21 مليار[1][2]تعداد الهند عام 2011ق. 1.32 مليار[3]تقديرات عام 2017ق. 30.8 مليون[4]مناطق الوجود المميزةبلد الأصل الهند البلد الهند  الهند نيبال 4,000,000[5] الولايات المتحدة 3,982,398[6] الإمارا…

Dutch poet Hanny Michaelis (1966) Hanny Michaelis (19 December 1922 – 11 June 2007) was a Dutch poet.[1] The daughter of Alfred Michaelis and Gonda Sara Swaab, both Jewish, she was born in Amsterdam.[1] Her parents were sent to Sobibór in 1943[2] and never returned. She lived in hiding from 1942 to 1945.[3] After World War II, Michaelis worked for the Artistic Affairs department of the municipality of Amsterdam .[4] In 1948, she married the writer G…

哈比卜·布尔吉巴الحبيب بورقيبة‎第1任突尼斯总统任期1957年7月25日—1987年11月7日(30年105天)总理巴希·拉德加姆(英语:Bahi Ladgham)(1969年-1970年)赫迪·努伊拉(英语:Hedi Nouira)(1970年-1980年)穆罕默德·姆扎利(英语:Mohammed Mzali)(1980年-1986年)拉希德·斯法尔(英语:Rachid Sfar)(1986年-1987年)宰因·阿比丁·本·阿里(1987年)继任宰因·阿比丁·本·阿…

Land managed by Native American nations under the US Bureau of Indian Affairs This article is about Native American reservations in the United States of America. For similar entities in Canada, see Indian reserve. For similar terms, see Indian reserve (disambiguation). Not to be confused with Reservation in India. This article needs to be updated. Please help update this article to reflect recent events or newly available information. (July 2022) Indian reservationsAlso known as:Domestic depende…

  لمعانٍ أخرى، طالع سقوط بغداد (توضيح). سقوط بغداد (2003) جزء من حرب العراق  تمثال صدام حسين وهو يسقط في ساحة الفردوس معلومات عامة التاريخ 3–9 نيسان/أبريل 2003[1] البلد العراق  الموقع بغداد، العراق33°20′00″N 44°26′00″E / 33.333333333333°N 44.433333333333°E / 33.333333333333; 44.43333333…

Liga Dunia Bola Voli FIVBLiga Dunia Bola Voli FIVBOlahragaBola voliDidirikan1990Dibubarkan2017Jumlah tim12 dalam Grup 112 dalam Grup 212 dalam Grup 3BenuaInternasional (FIVB)Juaraterakhir Prancis (gelar ke-2)Juara terbanyak Brasil (9 gelar) Liga Dunia Bola Voli FIVB (Inggris: FIVB Volleyball World League) atau hanya disebut World League adalah kompetisi bola voli internasional putra yang diselenggarakan setiap tahun oleh Federasi Bola Voli Internasional (FIVB). Versi wanita dari kompet…

Kembali kehalaman sebelumnya