On 19 January 2013, Arfani made his first Indonesia Super League appearance in Persita's starting XI in a 1–1 draw with Persipura Jayapura at the Mashud Wisnusaputra Stadium.[4] He scored his first Super League goal of the 2013 season on 13 February 2013, scored a brace in a 3–1 home win over Persiba Balikpapan.[5] He scored his goal on 27 April 2013, an equaliser in a 3–1 away lose over Persela Lamongan.[6]
In January 2015, he signed with Persepam Madura United.[9] however, he is not making any appearances for his current club due to this season was officially discontinued by PSSI on 2 May 2015 due to a ban by Imam Nahrawi, Minister of Youth and Sports Affairs, against PSSI to run any football competition.[10]
Return to Persita Tangerang
In early 2017, Arfani decided to re-join former club Persita Tangerang. Arfani scored his first league goal in the 2017 Liga 2 for Persita in a 2–0 win over Persika Karawang.[11]
On 23 June 2019, Arfani made his Liga 2 appearance in a match against PSGC Ciamis and then scored his first goal for the club in the injury time.[13] On 2 July 2019, Arfani scored a hat-trick during a 4–0 win over Persibat Batang.[14] with this result, he is listed as the first hat-trick in 2019 Liga 2.[15] Arfani finished the season as leading Liga 2 goalscorer, with 14 goals, two ahead of Persiraja Banda Aceh striker Assanur Rijal in second and also successfully brought his team back to promotion to the Liga 1.[16][17]
Arfani made his league debut on 6 March 2020 in new season 2020 Liga 1, coming on as a substitute for Samsul Arif in a 1–1 draw against PSM Makassar.[18] And then, This season was suspended on 27 March 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The season was abandoned and was declared void on 20 January 2021. Arfani made his new season league debut on 28 August 2021 in a match against Persipura Jayapura at the Pakansari Stadium where he coming as a substitute for Ahmad Nur Hardianto.[19]