ARTIKELDIGITAL.COM

created using {{navbox}}. It can be transcluded on pages by placing {{Criticism}} below the standard article appendices and above categories. This template's...

articles with Criticism, Controversy or similarly-titled sections that segregate a series of negative details into one section. Note that criticism and controversy...

{{navbox}}. It can be transcluded on pages by placing {{Pulitzer Prize for Criticism}} below the standard article appendices and above categories. This template's...

may be used: {{Criticism of religion|state=collapsed}} will show the template collapsed, i.e. hidden apart from its title bar. {{Criticism of religion|state=expanded}}...

articles with Criticism, Controversy or similarly-titled sections that segregate a series of negative details into one section. Note that criticism and controversy...

used: {{Literary criticism|state=collapsed}} will show the template collapsed, i.e. hidden apart from its title bar. {{Literary criticism|state=expanded}}...

documentation Stub hierarchy Lit-criticism-stub Criticism-stub Stub This template is used to identify a literary criticism-related stub. It uses {{article...

{{user talk criticism}} {{user talk criticism | otherusers = yes | endtext = This is an example. }} List of all parameters: {{user talk criticism | usepagename...

Lit-criticism-book-stub Lit-criticism-stub Criticism-stub Stub This template is used to identify a stub about a non-fiction book on literary criticism. It...

documentation Stub hierarchy Bible-criticism-stub Criticism-stub Stub This template is used to identify a stub about biblical criticism. It uses {{article stub box}}...

t e Template documentation Stub hierarchy Criticism-stub Stub This template is used to identify a criticism-related stub. It uses {{article stub box}}...

documentation Stub hierarchy Art-criticism-stub Criticism-stub Stub This template is used to identify a art criticism-related stub. It uses {{article stub...

documentation Stub hierarchy Textual-criticism-stub Criticism-stub Stub This template is used to identify a textual criticism-related stub. It uses {{article...

documentation Stub hierarchy Music-criticism-stub Criticism-stub Stub This template is used to identify a music criticism-related stub. It uses {{article...

articles with Criticism, Controversy or similarly-titled sections that segregate a series of negative details into one section. Note that criticism and controversy...

Template documentation Category:Criticism of postmodernism Editors can experiment in this template's sandbox (create | mirror) and testcases (create)...

used: {{Arts criticism navigation|state=collapsed}} will show the template collapsed, i.e. hidden apart from its title bar. {{Arts criticism navigation|state=expanded}}...

Template documentation To use this template, add it to your user page: {{no-criticism}} Search for transclusions. Editors can experiment in this template's...

{{user talk criticism}} {{user talk criticism | otherusers = yes | endtext = This is an example. }} List of all parameters: {{user talk criticism | usepagename...

This article is of a series on Criticism of religion By religion Baháˈí Faith Buddhism Christianity Catholic Jehovah's Witnesses Latter Day Saint movement...

history ) ... that white male Protestants dominated the field of biblical criticism for over 200 years, but globalization and multiple new perspectives of...

{{user talk criticism}} {{user talk criticism | otherusers = yes | endtext = This is an example. }} List of all parameters: {{user talk criticism | usepagename...

may be used: {{Criticism of religion|state=collapsed}} will show the template collapsed, i.e. hidden apart from its title bar. {{Criticism of religion|state=expanded}}...

documentationviewedithistorypurge {{WikiProject Bible |importance= |attention= |criticism= |category= }} Template:User WikiProject Bible The above documentation...

Articles with criticism or controversy sections (refresh) All articles 581 Template documentationviewedithistorypurge This is a progress box template...

31 May 2016 (UTC) ( Back to TM:TDYK Article history ) ....that self-criticism is a risk factor for depression and also impacts the treatment of depression...

Christianity subproject tags --> |bible= |bible-importance= |biblical-criticism= |biblical criticism-importance= |jesus-work-group= |theology-work-group= |theology-importance=...

To add an article to this category add {{Criticism section|date={{{month name}}} {{{year}}}}} to the article. If you omit the date a bot will add it for...

for this nom will be logged at Template talk:Did you know nominations/Criticism of Walmart; consider watching this nomination, if it is successful, until...

controversial topics into [[Category:Wikipedia controversial topics]]. {{Criticism section}}, for use within articles that have a Controversy section that...

(do not include any quotemarks): philosophy orgs events issues people criticism films Editors can experiment in this template's sandbox (create | mirror)...

work group, add your username to: Wikipedia:WikiProject Bible/Biblical criticism work group#Participants Place {{User WPBC}} on your user page to display...

to identify a stub about a non-fiction book on literature or literary criticism. It uses {{article stub box}}, which is a meta-template designed to ease...

70 years later, as the two strands of feminist literary criticism - 'Images Of Woman Criticism' and 'Gynocritics': the analysis of recurrent themes and...

authorize derivative works. Per § 107 it is believed that reproduction for criticism, comment, teaching and scholarship constitutes fair use and does not infringe...

account of a new user's experience before and after joining the project, criticism or praise of the project, first-person accounts of surviving deadly hurricanes...

|albums-work-group=yes |anglicanism=yes |baptist-work-group=yes |bible=yes |biblical-criticism=yes |calvinism=yes |catholicism=yes |charismatic-christianity=yes |china-work-group=yes...

Antisemitism has generated controversy over its inclusion of examples of criticism of Israel? Source: Kenneth L. Marcus (17 July 2015). The Definition of...

think the criticism section is redundant because its just copy-pasted from the finals article, and is only about the final and not about criticism from across...

...

of low-resolution of currency used for the purposes of commentary or criticism relating to the image of the currency itself where no free equivalent...

removing peacocking and puffery or by reverting the blanking of well-sourced criticism. If the article/edit also has problems with neutrality, however, then...

states that criticism takes help of science but criticism is not science rather it is branch of literature" would become he states: "Criticism takes the...

done and image nonexistent. However, the final section, Drawbacks and criticism, would be best expressed in continuous prose rather than bullet points...

pioneer of Indonesian literary criticism? ALT1:... that Zuber Usman was an early pioneer of Indonesian literary criticism? Reviewed: Mike Jolly Created/expanded...

section on "Criticism". While I understand a CSECTION is not against the "rules", I am of the opinion that separating it always gives criticism undue weight...

received both praise for its depiction of a lesbian relationship and criticism for how it adapted a First Nations story? Praise: "In this beautiful tale...

did not apply because... while the page contains negative content and criticism, it does not appear to be intended "purely to harass or intimidate a person"...

Academy of Literature (pictured) as he was upset by voices of official criticism of the Freemason movement? Created/expanded by Cezary Baryka (talk). Self...

received recognition for his outstanding command of military strategy and criticism for the harshness of the "scorched earth" policies that he implemented...

viewing area, terrace, bar and two restaurants. However, it has drawn criticism for its limited greenery.Photograph: Colin Archive – More featured pictures...

Christianity subproject tags --> |bible= |bible-importance= |biblical-criticism= |biblical criticism-importance= |jesus-work-group= |theology-work-group= |theology-importance=...

the National Reconnaissance Office and launched in 2013. This logo drew criticism following the ongoing surveillance disclosures; satirist Jon Stewart described...

Bill, 2018 introduced by the Indian Parliament was met with protests and criticism by the transgender community? Source: Colleges join hands to protest against...

citation. All other sources used are okay. I'm just not sure if the 'Criticism' section should be expanded first or it's accepted. Other than that, I...

necessary to describe the criticism as "significant" in the article. The source also doesn't directly attribute the criticism to Nintendo. On the hook...

manner (criticism of the album as a whole, followed by Morris' songwriting, followed by examples of specific song criticism, then by criticism about the...

was not a great success, with Burnand's libretto coming in for the most criticism, but its music exhibits many of the qualities and techniques that Sullivan...

of Atuan tells the coming-of-age story of a young girl, but received criticism for its treatment of gender? ALT1:... that Ursula K. Le Guin's 1971 novel...

about 'criticism', and is structured in the usual form (education, work, etc.). But our biography seems significanty focused on his recent criticism of the...

night sky and was inspired by the Cremorne Gardens in London, drew heated criticism from art critic John Ruskin, who accused Whistler of "flinging a pot of...

adjoining Piazza San Pietro. He fell from favour in later neoclassical criticism of the Baroque, but art historians in the 19th century and onwards have...

act and speak freely, while respecting other editors. I welcome advice, criticism and conversation. You may find these useful: {{Tps}} {{Outdent}} {{Resolved}}...

prominent criticisms directed against the ‘living instrument’ interpretative approach"; it would be nice to have some of those prominent criticisms summarized...

explanatory notes on protocol pages becoming extremely detailed. See also Criticism of Wikipedia § Excessive rule-making and Wikipedia:Content forking/Internal...

complete. I'm striking ALT 1, as it focuses on a criticism against the schedule/team. That criticism is worth mentioning in the article, but doesn't need...

of a tarred-and-feathered outlaw remains a metaphor for severe public criticism. This picture shows German-American farmer John Meints, of Luverne, Minnesota...

"partsuf": "", "items": { "bible": "Bible", "biblical-criticism": "Biblical criticism", "jesus-work-group": "Jesus", "theology-work-group":...

Nudity on the main page is... generally something which draws a lot of criticism. I wouldn't put Dream of the Fisherman's Wife (a notable woodcut) on POTD...

estimate has been highly contested and rejected by several historians. Criticism of Grabowski in question has been removed from the article by user Icewhiz...

Part of a series on Criticism of Islamism Muslim Critics Maajid Nawaz Ed Husain Reza Aslan Khaled Abu al-Fadl Muhammad Sa'id al-'Ashmawi Non-Muslim Critics...

severe criticism before they introduced this show. In that context, the current criticism is largely a continuation of the ongoing criticism of the station...

{{WikiProject Bible |importance= |attention= |criticism= |category= }} Template:User WikiProject Bible...

that Sophie Ellis-Bextor's 2001 cover of "Take Me Home" by Cher received criticism from the latter, for having "overtly sexual" new lyrics? ALT1:... that...

Interchange railway station was completely redesigned in response to criticism of the original proposal? Source: "Architects impressions of Wickham rail...

something else specifically, let me know. I've also changed the criticism piece to read as a criticism of the original formulation, especially since DeLancey actually...

ways to shop and stroll.". And there's no "Criticism" section, although the sources provide examples of criticism) 3. b) It cites its sources (although the...

(talk). Self nominated at 05:59, 9 June 2013 (UTC). Not a full review: The criticism of trees only appears in the caption of the image, without reference....

perspective that made itself known through his often aggressive and biting criticism of others" is from the LOC article and is attributed, by the citation...

explanation there is lack of "other side". There is news coverage regarding "criticism of the award returners", it seems that various well known people have...

Christianity subproject tags --> |bible= |bible-importance= |biblical-criticism= |biblical criticism-importance= |jesus-work-group= |theology-work-group= |theology-importance=...

leaves and dragonflies hovering over stagnant water is likely a veiled criticism of Mongol rule.Artist: Qian Xuan Archive – More featured pictures......

initiated and led arts criticism research projects in Thailand in the early 2000s? Source: Nagavajara, Chetana (2003). Criticism as an Intellectual Force...

could potentially mention the criticism of racial inequality, the praise saying it should be "in all libraries", criticism about the "entire swaths of the...

that of its sources. Compare for example "After widespread international criticism, however, the convictions were overturned by Bahrain's attorney general...

wouldn't be undue. As it is, there is a lot of criticism in the article because there's been a lot of criticism in real life. WP articles reflect reality,...

episodes in three decades of the series" ALT1:... that Casualty received criticism for a series 29 episode which featured a crash that viewers believed resembled...

sources. In a scholarly context, the word "myth" is not meant to be a criticism. There is a consensus on the article's talk page to say "creation myth";...

spaceship Mark Zuckerberg (pictured) in the music video for "Ay mamá" is criticism of Meta's censorship of female nipples? ALT1: ... that the cover art and...

Talk:Muhammad Talk:Quran Talk:Criticism of Islam Talk:Battle of Khaybar Talk:Banu Qurayza Talk:Kaaba - Picture of Muhammad debate Ka'bah - WP:BRD - Spelling...

ISBN 978-93-88540-55-1. ALT1: ... that Abdul Ahad Azad laid the foundations of literary criticism in Kashmiri literature? Source: Gauhar, G. N., 1934- (1997). Abdul Ahad...

article. The hook is cited. But the source cited seems to be a reply to criticism of the hypothesis that C. fulvipunctata is an anti-Lessepsian migrant...

about the neutrality requirement. There's stuff in the article about criticism, but nothing about support, or even why the sponsors (and governor, and...

high standard from all nominated articles, but polite and constructive criticism is expected – do not be unkind. REPLACE THIS CAPITALISED TEXT WITH THE...

account of a new user's experience before and after joining the task force, criticism or praise of the task force, first-person accounts of surviving deadly...

the 1930s, but declined following World War II. The growth of feminist criticism in the 1970s helped re-establish her reputation. She suffered from ongoing...

(UTC) @Mehediabedin: I was going to promote this, but I find that the "Criticism" section does not comply with WP:NPOV. A lot of the statements in this...

Self-Portrait with Cigarette (pictured) by Edvard Munch was met with criticism of its "degeneration"? Source: Berman 1993, p. 629 Reviewed: Battle of...

blog, Global Sisters) aren't reliable. The article also seems to lack criticism of the term's use in the US and Canada, so both of this issue remains...

to author Writing the Record: The Village Voice and the Birth of Rock Criticism? Source: "It was only in talking to one of my professors, Siva Vaidhyanathan...

article. It has 1587 characters, and 1278 of them are on controversies/criticism of the hospital. The only details on the hospital given in the article...

Suryani (pictured) performed multiple patriotic songs, she also made veiled criticism of President Sukarno? Reviewed: Konsert Lentera Timur Created by Drmies...

archetypal depiction of Australian culture in his comedy received journalistic criticism? ALT4:... that Neel Kolhatkar's first major acting role was in the divisive...

Back to TM:TDYK Article history ) ... that "Long Way to Go" received criticism for its sample of "I Have a Dream"? Reviewed: Cut Sleeve Improved to Good...

the "criticism" section are not attributed to anyone. I disagree. I have provided the source for each of the points in the article's criticism section...

TM:TDYK Article history ) ... that the Jersey scrum-half Will Homer led criticism of plans by the Rugby Football Union to cut funding to RFU Championship...

copy-editing, added her religion, that she has no school of criticism, that she was against New Criticism, that her Oxford Book was also published in braille...

controversial topics into [[Category:Wikipedia controversial topics]]. {{Criticism section}}, for use within articles that have a Controversy section that...

rounds of inspections of field organizations,and was fully aware of the criticism generated by his use of a special train for that purpose." ([1] (p. 267)...

be developed in future to describe the circumstances that resulted in criticism of Campbell, not just for an alleged affair, but as the matron of a hospital...

Prize for her poem, Two Lovers and a Beachcomber by the Real Sea."[1] Criticism: "Her dissatisfaction with her previous work became a sweeping, self-castigating...

paragraph lays out that it's a criticism from workers that the branding did not align with their reality as workers, and that criticism is what I've captured....

Stand-alone "defense" and "criticism" is typically integrated into one reception section, maybe put the defense last since the criticism section sums up the...

wrote the column in The Forward first, to give context to why he received criticism from both sides of the political spectrum. I'm unsure of using the term...

see it cited in the article. Also, the bulk of the article is Plot and Criticism. The lead has the only "meat" on the page. Could you expand this with...

since this article passed through a GA review, and WP:CRIT states that a criticism section is sometimes appropriate. The hook is sourced to an offline source...

19:15, 24 April 2014 (UTC) Dear Gerda, again thanks for your helpful criticism. I've now added an infobox and a list of some of the catalogues that went...

problem with the character. ツStacey (talk) 09:30, 10 August 2016 (UTC) The criticism was directed at the Scott Drinkwell character, which the producer defended...

Ballard's weakest works? Source: see ref 5 and 6, with quotations, for criticism, and reference 7 for the connection Reviewed: Template:Did you know nominations/Stuck:...

source and are in article. No textual issues (though I wish the Roys criticism was also in body, HistoryTheorist. Hook decision is promoter's call, though...

Fuccbois' crew won awards, while Fuccboi's prose received both praise and criticism? Reviewed: Discrimination against people with red hair, Volodymyr Kozhukhar...

that the women's suffrage journal Jus Suffragii (logo pictured) drew criticism during World War I for launching "an active pacifist campaign"? Reviewed:...

of Mormon Thought? ALT1:... that Martha Sonntag Bradley-Evans received criticism for her active voice in Mormon feminism while she was a professor of history...

required to act with appropriate decorum. While grievances, complaints, or criticism of the foundation are frequently posted here, you are expected to present...

has been perceived as losing its moral high ground with regards to its criticism of the problems with Japanese history textbooks? ALT1:... that the recent...

Article history ) ... that American colonial pastor Matthew Wilson answered criticism that he was too engaged in politics by writing "Liberty" on his hat and...

expert opinion, which describes these sites as unreliable. From published criticisms (1 2 3 4 5), it is clear that these analyses violate basic methodological...

November 2014 (UTC) ( Back to TM:TDYK Article history ) ... that following criticism, UK suicide prevention charity Samaritans discontinued their Twitter-based...

and get his degree? ALT1:... that Ezra Pound's first work of literary criticism, The Spirit of Romance (pictured), has many similarities to his lengthy...

close paraphrasing. @CactiStaccingCrane: The majority of the prose for "Criticism and controversies" section is duplicated from earlier sections in the...

"creative genius": W. S. Howell, "Poetics, rhetoric, and logic in Renaissance criticism" in Robert Bolgar, ed., Classical Influences on European Culture, A.D...

which is here, and makes it much clearer that this study was an answer to criticism, rather than raising them. (The Guardian article is vague on that point)...

May 2013 (UTC) I've put it in inverted commas. That has to be the funniest criticism of my work so far :) Gareth E Kegg (talk) 22:14, 5 May 2013 (UTC)...

identify a about a non-fiction book on American literature or literary criticism stub. It uses {{article stub box}}, which is a meta-template designed...

directly though, it might make an interesting read to see contemporaryish criticism and that several millennia hence intermingled. The articles a good to...

"one of the best albums released so far that year", but that's the only criticism I have for this nomination. All in all, good to go. — AJDS talk 17:16...

keep it simple as a new article without going into to much fandom or criticism. new enough, long enough, nice new article with good sources. hook is...

David Blatherwick advised the British Prime Minister on how to respond to criticism following the deaths of hunger strikers in Northern Ireland? Comment:...

{{Format link|Primal therapy#Criticism}} {{Format link}} Primal therapy § Criticism {{Format link/sandbox}} Primal therapy § Criticism Kung Fu Dino Posse {{Format...

logic. Just either one extra section or some sentences of criticism (positive counts as criticism, too, am I right?), and that's it. Nothing more, nothing...

to the artist. It is believed that using this image for commentary or criticism relating to the image or to the design of the coin itself, for identification...

Indonesia - Lontar Foundation collaboration. Please leave constructive criticism to assist the editor in further improving her contributions. Created/expanded...

repeatedly offered release from Mezzeh prison if he would recant his criticism of the Syrian government, but refused? ALT1:... that Syrian dissident...

ride on a nuclear submarine because she was a woman, Adele Ferguson's criticism of the Navy attracted so much attention she was offered a personal tour...

is Kuliczkowska was praising the criticism of the "filthy rich" character and criticizing the lack of such criticism of another character (she was writing...

its title? Source: Mr Virgin bringing a ‘sex comedy’ to the mainstream "Criticism of Mr Virgin’s title follows an incident earlier this year where the movie...

accused Shinzo Abe and Chuck Hagel of provocation, in response to their criticism of China's actions in the South China Sea? Reviewed: Province of Pavia...

many parodies? ALT1: ... that "Christmas Day in the Workhouse" was a criticism of the harsh conditions in English workhouses under the 1834 Poor Law...

this, please take particular care to avoid personal attack or personal criticism here. If you want to say anything about an editor please do it at that...

coverage in sources independent of the subject. The first paragraph under Criticism mentions that he has been criticized by several sources, but there is...

—Cliftonian (talk) 13:00, 20 February 2012 (UTC) Sport articles have a criticism for that. I don't think it is particularly problematic. It can be hard...

found this after some quick searches including phrases like bias and criticism. Palfreyman is I believe employed as an advocate. If another editor care...

aspect a bit more, perhaps using a source such as Banana Bending: "This criticism was raised recently, and often repeated, about the film version of The...

to denote "worked for a magazine"? Other issues: what does "academic criticism" mean in this context? what are Spandan Samman and Madhuban Vyanga Shri...

Andy Lamey’s book, Duty and the Beast, offers the first, book-length criticism of the new omnivorist position(s)." -- Christopher Bobier Created by J...

- I have now changed the lead to source the criticism. Also I deleted a couple of sentences of criticism and added benefit to the current account to make...

January 2026 (UTC). Policy compliance: Adequate sourcing: Neutral: - the criticism section could be tweaked. for instance, "When marginalized racial groups...

response to the criticism of the password save system. Surtsicna (talk) 19:11, 21 April 2023 (UTC) @Surtsicna: It was definitely a criticism that the game...

(do not include any quotemarks): philosophy orgs events issues people criticism films Editors can experiment in this template's sandbox (create | mirror)...

out to sources cited; a QPQ is not required. Looks good to go. My only criticism is that I don't think the number of stage wins and podiums stated in the...

China suffered not one but three centuries of humiliation? Source: Why criticism of the Qing dynasty scares the Communist Party : "But the 1644 view—cheekily...

without using citation templates) ALT1:... that ...? Source: "Despite criticism and modification by several authors, some researchers still use the HST...

a particular author for the use of taverns, but not their generalized criticism of alcohol consumption. Old School WWC Fan (talk) 03:51, 17 March 2018...

Bloom wrote more than 50 books, including over 40 books of literary criticism, several books discussing religion, and one novel. He edited hundreds...

occasionally scientistic) "psychology of art", while omitting centuries of art criticism that one would expect to find in the article on "art and emotion". Maybe...

sources/Noticeboard/Archive 268#Breitbart as a source for criticism of Wikipedia |discussion4=Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive...

references. Δρ.Κ. λόγοςπράξις 15:12, 21 April 2013 (UTC) Please work with the criticism listed above, or we will have to close this nomination.—♦♦ AMBER(ЯʘCK)...

This article is of a series on Criticism of religion By religion Baha'i Faith Buddhism Christianity Christian fundamentalism Catholic Anti-Catholicism...

"Criticism" and "Defense", as the latter section is about four times longer than the former. The article seems like it's trying to bludgeon criticism to...

Christian Hauge, five years before Hauge resigned under increasing public criticism? Source: Kristoffersen, Roger (1995). HOF's historie (in Norwegian). Oslo:...

maybe some bit could be included about how this was done because of criticism? I personally think this article is good for DYK, so tell me if there...

coin designs. It is believed that using this image: for commentary or criticism relating to the image or to the design of the coin itself, for identification...

criticism of the agenda is blockquoted, since she's a very reliable source (political science professor at Harvard). There's no shortage of criticism...

videos"? Source: CTV News ALT1:... that Canada's Bill C-10 has faced criticism for potentially classifying social media services as broadcasters? Source:...

or any other form of mainstream criticism. Onceinawhile (talk) 22:51, 15 May 2021 (UTC) I'm not asking for criticism of the Nakba, just for the Israeli...

DYK requires every section to be referenced, so the sections Literary criticism and Novels need references. SL93 (talk) 15:39, 19 November 2022 (UTC)...

with the material available that was probably unavoidable, so it's no criticism of the creator. The hook fact is neutral and properly formatted. It is...

mentioning it in a few quotes from other sources. Of course relevant criticism can be added (in fact it already exists in the article), but in order...

controversial topics into [[Category:Wikipedia controversial topics]]. {{Criticism section}}, for use within articles that have a Controversy section that...

have made some edits to the article which should address some of your criticisms. Now the hook sentence in the article should have a reputable academic...

colonizados". ("The sculpture was a criticism of the cynicism of the colonizers [...] it is a concise, clean and clear criticism of Hispanic cynicism towards...

of the Spotify spokesperson. Was it joking? (I think it was.) Was it criticism? (I doubt it.) I also don't like the hidden piped link to John Cage's...

reworded to read: ALT1 ... that the Yiddish poet David Einhorn levelled criticism at other Jewish writers in Berlin whom he accused of being "bourgeois...

sources for the claims backed up by these sources, particularly in the "criticism" section, or offer some thoughts on why these sources are appropriate...

make it clear that the preceding paragraph includes Aquinas' criticism [1]. "Criticism" now has its own section. As for the other supporters of the theory...

(whom I have voted for in the past), I only included that quote as a criticism of the law. Furthermore, no fraud was committed as the police dropped...

and worst of all "suffering a disgraceful defeat" which appears to be a criticism of the referee. Cwmhiraeth (talk) 07:38, 11 February 2015 (UTC) @Cwmhiraeth:...

and details of the Glacier View meeting itself Add to "Adventist Responses to Criticisms" section, ideally with material from Adventist scholars etc....

enough, new enough. QPQ is fine. However it's classed as a stub, and the criticism section is bullet points rather than a paragraph. The previous version...

has written poems intended to inspire military revolution, including criticism of the Moroccan Western Sahara Wall? Source:https://thequietus...

removing peacocking and puffery or by reverting the blanking of well-sourced criticism. If the article/edit also has problems with neutrality, however, then...

contended to be fair use when it is used for the purposes of commentary or criticism relating to the image of the currency itself. Any other uses of the British...

railroad agreed to pay in exchange for Weisberg moderating her public criticism of the railroad and its president, Albert Dudley. And sorry about the...

when that criticism is legitimate, but that does not appear to be the case here. In light of the entry's substantial sourcing, this criticism is unclear...

DYK policy against negative hooks about a living person. Presumably the criticism of "Amy Wyatt"'s makeup was in response to the actual non-fictional makeup...

required 1.5k. Article is written in a neutral manner, without undue criticism or praise. Each paragraph is replete with inline citations. No copying...

gameplay trailer featuring Mass Effect: Andromeda's Sara Ryder drew such criticism over her facial animations that BioWare issued a public apology before...

adequte. Article is neutral in tone, and provides balanced praise and criticism. No plagiarism issures detected. Hooked is cited from an offline source...

puns in his History of Philosophy series has attracted both praise and criticism? Source: "Praising the puns Criticising the puns. Both are cited in the...

article, obviously) and all of them were positive with little negative criticism, I think that defines the term "critically acclaimed". All the term means...

Iselilja (talk) 16:53, 29 April 2013 (UTC) Please work with abovementioned criticism, otherwise we will need to delist this nomination in the upcoming days...

passengers. Example from Henri L'Estrange#Sydney Harbour crossing: Despite the criticism, L'Estrange performed at least once more at Middle Harbour, although crowds...

officials" is supposed to be sourced in the article, and I agree with the criticism of it, but anyway I much prefer the greater specificity of ALT1, which...

February 2013 (UTC). ( Back to TM:TDYK Article history ) ... that UN criticism of the exclusion of women from the line of succession to the Liechtensteiner...

Christine (Figureskatingfan) (talk) 21:01, 31 May 2021 (UTC) To your citation criticism: Ref1 was to connect Ruskin to Transcendental ideals, not plein air painting...

this very down-to-earth-boring-politician biography, and the implied criticism is also pretty tame. --Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul Piotrus| reply here...

Olympics? Since the campaign has ended, it's fine to mention some of the criticism it received; some of those quotes are pretty funny. QPQ done. Yoninah...

is my 3rd DYK review, please let me know if you have any constructive criticism. Chef Vortex (talk) 00:31, 10 June 2021 (UTC) Just to be clear, Earwig...

explanatory notes on protocol pages becoming extremely detailed. See also Criticism of Wikipedia § Excessive rule-making and Wikipedia:Content forking/Internal...

all-positive description and information be balanced by e.g. examples of any criticism or negative comparison, or perhaps the name(s) of product(s) which superseded...

for a claim that controversial, I'd ask for a secondary source on the criticism itself. Howzabout we let the organization speak for itself? theleekycauldron...

(talk) 23:20, 9 March 2016 (UTC) Thank you, Gamaliel. That is a valid criticism and I have slightly tweaked the original hook and proposed it as an alternative...

This editnotice (for Criticism of Wikipedia (edit | talk | history | links | watch | logs)) is set never to expire. To adjust this setting, please update...

the Scottish judge William Honyman, Lord Armadale was singled out for criticism in John Wade's The Black Book: Or, Corruption Unmasked? Reviewed: Forge...

(UTC) Thank you. I also removed that fact from the lead; it sounds like criticism of her, not notability. ALT1 is actually a better hook!. ALT1 hook ref...

the early-morning Columbia Lectures in International Studies to offset criticism of its prime-time schedule of crime show reruns? Source: see fn 10 in...

This editnotice (for Criticism of Israel (edit | talk | history | links | watch | logs)) is set never to expire. To adjust this setting, please update...

third section. Also, we have Big Tech as a wikipedia article along with criticism, which is also a similar "perjorative" against tech companies, and other...

haven't praised Keogh to the same extent Ryan did; if anything to avoid criticism like this. - Shudde talk 07:50, 3 April 2013 (UTC) OK. I consider it as...

Back to TM:TDYK Article history ) ... that in rejecting so-called "New Criticism," Robert Kaske argued that medieval poetry needs to be read in context...

rejected by the Konbaung court for what the court considered to be harsh criticisms of the prior Burmese chronicles? Reviewed: Martin Høyem Created/expanded...

Nikkimaria (talk) 02:51, 3 July 2012 (UTC) Thanks for the constructive criticism. In assembling this quickly I see that I did include too many directly...

compliance: Adequate sourcing: Neutral: - I think you should mention the criticism of the book, for example [5] and [6]. Also, "bestselling" is a term that...

the name in a scientific journal and thus its acceptance while avoiding criticism of English-speaking scientists, he had to submit it to a Polish journal...

"terrible" that her husband could not buy a Porsche Cayenne for fear of public criticism? Source: "Et de poursuivre : « Avec mon mari on aime les belles bagnoles...

article about an interesting concept. Article is new and long enough. The Criticism section seems to focus on externalities causing BUMDes to flounder and...

building's real criticisms will come with time -- I looked and couldn't find any, using "Manitoba Hydro Place" and terms like "criticism," "downside," "negative"...

I've now vastly improved the sourcing on the final section to avoid any criticism of it failing WP:V. I'm open to suggestions of new hooks; personally I...

would sometimes use train to commute the campus in order to listen in criticisms about the campus? Regards, Jeromi Mikhael 01:54, 11 February 2023 (UTC)...

questioned? Source: The fact is supported by sources [5] and [6] in the “Criticism, controversies and Regulation” section. Reviewed: [[1]] Comment: Submitting...

and that's not terribly uncommon in radio articles. I agree with your criticism and suggest ALT1: Sammi Brie (she/her • t • c) 04:39, 10 April 2022 (UTC)...

and article. They are related but not the same. 2. The sentence "direct criticism of the Supreme Court over its handling of the criminal contempt case involving...

tで、47NEWSとの関係も不明瞭だったため、逆にまとめ人への批判コメントも。" "The account singled out for criticism this time was "@47news," which broadcasts news headlines from "47NEWS"...

death of Prince Philip, the Duke of Edinburgh, the broadcaster received criticism for the continuous coverage of the Duke? Source: BBC flooded with complaints...

the criteria I am supposed to follow), and if you have any constructive criticism to offer, I'd be glad to hear it. Chef Vortex (talk) 00:31, 10 June 2021...

Thanks. Good to go. -Zanhe (talk) 19:57, 1 March 2019 (UTC) Dumelow: not a criticism (great work ob the article!) but could you please clarify to me what it...

good to go. However, I will take this opportunity to offer some mild criticism, as well. Firstly, I think the second paragraph of the "Career" section...

Frederick Henry Ambrose; Edward Miller (1894). A Plain Introduction to the Criticism of the New Testament. Vol. 1. London: George Bell & Sons. p. 139. Reviewed:...

job here keeping us all honest. Didn't mean my comment above to be a criticism, just a reasoning as to why the sources didn't mention the source of the...

regarding your meaning, sorry. Thanks for the review, any further ideas/criticism is always welcome. 78.26 (spin me / revolutions) 21:07, 6 August 2018...

article, Ayn Rand, has frequently become the subject of controversies and criticisms regarding her and her philosophy. While suggestions to improve the content...

gov/title17/92chap1.html#107 § 107] it is believed that reproduction for criticism, comment, teaching and scholarship constitutes fair use and does not infringe...

groups around the country" same source as above ALT2:... that despite criticism of its "The woman who made up her mind" advert as sexist, Better Together...

a-semua-agama-bukan-wujud-toleransi/a-51196010 or another source; the criticism from the IUC is cited in the article but not at the URL above.) --Metropolitan90...

before I pass this is where it discusses the criticism of the basketballs on the statue. The criticism part is cited but the Twitter part is not and...

it a crack myself: I felt it was important to explain how the chef's criticism led to Tim racing, so added him watching the cars race followed by racing...

anything else of Mr. Gilbert's. ... It is really a very subtle piece of criticism, sometimes of Shakespeare’s play, sometimes of the commentators, sometimes...

cover all significant viewpoints under WP:POV. I don't believe that the criticism by "governments, corporations and local elites" (the use of local elites...

with consensus to merge Monthly clean-up category/Messages/Articles with criticism or controversy sections Monthly clean-up category/Messages/Articles with...

17 more years? Source: "In 1955...the Study received its first major criticism from outside the PHS orbit...physician Count D. Gibson... wrote...'I am...

the object of the article), article is new and neutral is so far as the criticism reported is supported by the sources. I thus think that the article is...

(certainly aligns with the material I can read on Google books. One slight criticism in that the article would benefit from some more geographical discussion...

Reich's theory; and in my opinion it also needs a lot more mention of criticism (for example, of the attitude toward masturbation; that leaps off the...

This editnotice (for Criticism of Amnesty International (edit | talk | history | links | watch | logs)) is set never to expire. To adjust this setting...

This editnotice (for Criticism of Hamas (edit | talk | history | links | watch | logs)) is set never to expire. To adjust this setting, please update...

January 2012 (UTC) Is that the Guild of non-collaboration and needless criticism? Or the Guild of copy editors who try and improve articles? Hopefully...

unnecessary quoting, and these quotes are given without context. Also, the criticism section begins "Many", but only references a campus newspaper whose article...

(mostly America) and the response to them. I know there has been more criticism than the risk of infection. However, if you can't find it, no worries...

including "first woman President of the Bahamian Senate"? Yes, there was criticism of all these "firsts" but this hook offers more than a "first". --Gerda...

were criticized for owning the dog? Their homosexuality might have drawn criticism, their dog ownership did not. Kevin McE (talk) 23:18, 16 March 2012 (UTC)...

Igiebor was held incommunicado for six months following his magazine's criticism of Nigerian General Sani Abacha? Reviewed: American Writers: A Journey...

any British monarch (96), and having the longest reign. She faced media criticism of her family over the breakups of her children's marriages, and after...

(UTC) ( Back to TM:TDYK Article history ) ... that The West Wing faced criticism for a scene in which Ainsley Hayes defends a sexist and objectifying remark...

up to me, but if I pass it as it stands I guarantee you there will be criticism at TRM's errors page, where someone else will just stick a section title...

04:11, 20 April 2013 (UTC) Nominator, please work with the abovementioned criticism, or this nomination will have to be removed.—♦♦ AMBER(ЯʘCK) 19:34, 4 May...

Article history links: Gigi Perez Sailor Song (song) ) ... that following criticism from far-right conservative Christian communities over a lyric in "Sailor...

WP:DYKNEW, there's no way this should be dedicating 4/5th of its prose to criticism of a 12 year old girl and I binned 2/3rds of it, meaning it's well under...

Nice work. @Johnson524: I wonder though whether the section titled "Criticism and awards" is appropriate since everything mentioned there seems to be...

motivating an editathon, a Marshall Plan, and a Wikimania under a cloud of criticism Special report NPR and AfC – The Marshall Plan: an engagement and a marriage...

"cannot be said to be about anything"? Source: R. M. Ogilvie, in fact, took criticism of the 'Thebaid' to, perhaps, its ultimate low point when he declared...

remaining at peace with the world. His presidency has often come under criticism for tolerating corruption and, in his second term, leading the nation...

work seems to be a travel book and the Button work seems to be literary criticism. While both may be trying to be historically accurate, any treatment of...

since its rareness is specifically mentioned in the hook itself. Not a criticism, just an observation. I'd help out and look up refs myself because that's...

one sort or another -- if not systematically -- for ALT1 not to attract criticism. I modestly recommend ALT2. EEng (talk) 04:09, 18 October 2014 (UTC) Good...

did not apply because... while the page contains negative content and criticism, it does not appear to be intended "purely to harass or intimidate a person"...

compliance: Adequate sourcing: Neutral: - The article does not attribute the criticism of the costume, without which it is not possible to assess whether these...

nominations/Lego Masters (French TV series) Comment: The paragraph about criticism probably needs a neutrality check, since the info might be undue... and...

Comment: (I don'think I'm very good at picking good hooks, so constructive criticism on the hooks would be appreciated, if you think they're not very good...

because it's an article about a living person that contains quite a bit of criticism. I think we should check with Brian Josephson before going ahead. SlimVirgin...

Smith, a Professor of Political Science at Trinity College. Smith drew criticism for referring to African-American, Asian-American, Latino, Muslim and...

Irish troubles to the troubles of movie star Frances Farmer, with lots of criticism of the stratification and sexism of the current social and economic system...

outside, of course, the issues of notability and lack of stability. So: criticism of IPN is controversial, and possibly undue. It is neither the main issue...

the iconic image of Capa. The crappy giant has received quite a bit of criticism in recent days." The ugly giant statue A few days ago, more and more people...

journalists interpreted Taylor Swift's song "But Daddy I Love Him" as her criticism at her own fans? Source: BBC, The New York Times Reviewed: Template:Did...

developer developing real estate, and the hook is that he voiced some criticism about a restaurant dish named after him. David notMD (talk) 10:58, 22...

very interesting - but I am not going to block this with a subjective criticism like this. That said, I'll suggest ALT1 below.--Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul...

I've ever seen in my life"? ALT1: ... that after Matty Healy dismissed criticism of his appearance on The Adam Friedland Show, Azealia Banks said he wasn't...

19:52, 25 April 2013 (UTC) It has been a few days. Please work with the criticism listed above.—♦♦ AMBER(ЯʘCK) 06:51, 30 April 2013 (UTC) See User talk:Rikster2#Taurence...

it just looks like U.S. bashing from a nation that has had plenty of criticism tossed its own way. I think you could develop a hook from the fact that...

Williams Tunnel, but wasn't a hit with Boston riders? Source: see the Criticism section, particularly this source cited in the article. Reviewed: WEBY...

fully understand that submitting/running a hook that implies any possible criticism of Donald Trump on the main page could be contentious, and I would like...

it one of the country's best selling albums? Alt 1 ... that Huang An's criticism of the K-pop singer Chou Tzu-yu for waving a Taiwanese flag on South Korean...

violation. The article cites sources perfectly and, commendably, includes criticism as well (which, I think, is not often the case). I find the hook to be...

there was some back-pedalling by Washington National Opera after initial criticism of the sponsorship, General Dynamics were ultimately one of the sponsors...

Yeghiazaryan experienced a creative crisis as a result of constructive criticism from Sergei Prokofiev? Source: Ibid., page 121 Reviewed: Template:Did...

Article history ) ... that when Alexander McQueen, following years of criticism for over-reliance on runway spectacles, presented The Man Who Knew Too...

being used to support anything controversial. I should also add that no criticism of this source was raised during the recent (and very thorough) GA review...

high standard from all nominated articles, but polite and constructive criticism is expected – do not be unkind. Example (edit|talk|history|links|watch|logs|google)...

it, please cite it, else remove it. There's also this sentence: After criticism for disparities in effectiveness between neighborhoods, the city implemented...

was unknown Source: Carter came under criticism for not helping the girl. Article: Carter came under criticism for not helping the child Source: To get...

convey the more subjective nature of the jersey criticism. Changing from a "controversy and criticism due to" formulation to a "criticized as" one might...

and Narutolovehinata5: I think the hangup is that even if there are no criticisms of the book+praises of Modi out there, even if this article entirely represents...

Wikpedia! Here's a little story: A college student was given constructive criticism in class by his professor. He bristled, getting angry. Then he stopped...

and criticism of the first film" vs "a temporary psychotic breakdown believed to have been brought on by the pressure of the success – and criticism – of...

Books. —Bloom6132 (talk) 23:00, 25 April 2013 (UTC) Please work with the criticism listed, otherwise we will regretfully have to take down this nomination...

1987, Thames & Hudson (US Harry N Abrams), ISBN 0500235104 ALT2:... that criticism of Michelangelo's Last Judgement in the Sistine Chapel began even before...

interesting, short, and cited in-line; I would hazard to add some of the criticisms from the source to the article. Image is clear, produces well at thumbnail...

nomination has failed, since the nominator is not taking action to work with criticism. Enough time has passed, and he has received a note on this talk page...

a=JnNpdGU9ZWRzLWxpdmUmc2NvcGU9c2l0ZQ%3d%3d#AN=136642390&db=ufh "Early criticism of the artwork centered on the mural's unreliable historicity and lewd...

inside quoation marks, so "close paraphrasing" would be an inappropriate criticism. "1970" now referenced. Edwardx (talk) 17:59, 5 January 2014 (UTC) Please...

they can be easily fixed) Can I suggest that changing the hook to avoid criticism is shirking responsibility. If we know this is wrong then we need to pull...

decision to overturn the constitutional right to abortion, which has drawn criticism around the world. Reviewed: Moved to mainspace by Vigilantcosmicpenguin (talk)...

already realized it wasn't too great after I nominated, and will take the criticism. A little short on time for Wiki-work atm, but will think about it and...

I think the first hook is better as it is less likely to be read as a criticism for the team. It is a bit long, perhaps lose the word 'forcefully'? The...

The official report is given prominent coverage and presented alongside criticism of it, and the timeline has multiple sources supporting it. With all that...

article is focused much more on the Pakistani side of the deal (evaluations/criticisms, for instance, do not mention any Chinese reactions at all). That is a...

can figure it out. Note: This is my first DYK review, and I am open to criticism and/or a second opinion. --LordPeterII (talk) 17:04, 23 April 2021 (UTC)...

23 September 2021 (UTC) ( Back to TM:TDYK Article history ) ... that criticism of armchair theorizing in anthropology has resulted in scholars "coming...

that the animated series Burka Avenger has received both praise and criticism for its portrayal of Pakistani culture? ALT5: ... that the Burka Avenger...

Main Page. The article is new enough, long enough, neutral (the focus on criticism seems to actually reflect the sources). Hook facts are sourced properly...

Separate "Criticism" sections usually aren't a good idea, and especially not when they contain only one sentence. This and any other criticisms should be...

nomination? StAnselm (talk) 04:54, 10 February 2013 (UTC) ALT1: ... that criticisms John Cotton (pictured) made of the doctrine of preparationism were a factor...

that could be misconstrued as spammy, addressed your line about lack of criticism, revamped the proposed hook and added an alt hook below. What do you think...

nominations/Second Thoughts are Best? If so, I note that that review is open to criticism for not mentioning issues like copyvio, but as it has none (I checked)...

However, looking at them again, there's an equal mix containing her criticism of the gender gap and systemic bias, so I think we do need a rethink....

employed a French sound engineer, with the intention to reverse the repeated criticism of the times: the bad sound quality of Venezuelan films" (Contrapunto)...

contended to be fair use when it is used for the purposes of commentary or criticism relating to the image of the currency itself. Any other uses of the British...

long enough sourced = nicely referenced neutral = good discussion of the criticism; all complying with NPOV plagiarismfree = Earwig's Copyvio Detector was...

grounds of the admiral's culpable delay and inactivity. Faced with public criticism from a relatively junior officer, Gambier felt he must demand a court...

take EEng's comment personally. I'm sure it is intended as constructive criticism. If you want your hook to make it onto the front page, you have to expect...

contextualizing the critical reviews; I've added a description into the 'Criticism' section to state that. And yes, the suggested ALT0a looks great! --Kbabej...

Slavery Concubinage Social welfare Women Related topics Arabic Apostasy Criticism Muhammad Quran Hadith Golden Age Other religions Islamism Islamophobia...

(source link ) ALT1:... that Deepika Padukone was subjected to massive criticism by members of the ruling BJP after her visit to stand in solidarity with...

mildly. LavaBaron (talk) 18:25, 16 May 2016 (UTC) That sort of unhelpful criticism won't win you any friends. If you had just replied to the effect of, "I...

(UTC) Apologies for the tardy follow-up, but I'm afraid that the same criticism of the article looking like a bunch of news items cobbled together still...

documentary's maker, whereas the article is positioning the text in question as a criticism of the documentary through the analysis of a media review. It's really...

This editnotice (for Israeli criticism of the occupation of Palestine (edit | talk | history | links | watch | logs)) is set never to expire. To adjust...

yourt accusation and objection before putting up frivolous objection or criticisms! David I must object to your review and I request you remove yourself...

signs, that's a fairly good place to add a small amount of appropriate criticism, which should deal with the issue. Adam Cuerden (talk) 19:09, 25 October...

(talk) 21:43, 18 January 2017 (UTC) @Yoninah: Thank you for your helpful criticism. I added many more cites. [1] Remain only few paragraphs without cites...

removing peacocking and puffery or by reverting the blanking of well-sourced criticism. If the article/edit also has problems with neutrality, however, then...

association of the caduceus with commerce has engendered significant criticism of its use in medicine. Medical professionals argue that the Rod of Asclepius...

criticized for ginger hair without putting it in the context that said criticism was itself criticized in The Guardian's opinion piece for being dogwhistle...

Revolution is also important (this was one of the primary contemporary criticisms levied at them by their opponents) and gives it international relevance...

further, and once that is done I will build out the lead. There's a lot of criticism written on this guy, and I am trying to assimilate the material in a way...

the strictest of Wikipedia's policies. If anyone were to offer negative criticism of this hook, then the person would be deemed to have issues. We cannot...

had criticism of Tokarska-Bakir without stating what this criticism was about (Freud). We also failed to mention that our sources of such criticism (Dobrosielski)...

Areas of study Anthropology Archaeology Architecture Art Art criticism Literary criticism Film theory Science fiction Biology Composition studies Criminology...

Eight simple rules for editing our encyclopedia Explanationism External criticism of Wikipedia Galileo complex Here to build an encyclopedia Leave it to...

17:01, 15 July 2014 (UTC) I don't think the hook is intended as direct criticism, rather it is to provoke curiosity and I note that the quote is in a piece...

additional references to the sources already footnoted. Open to constructive criticism about sensitive paraphrasing but the number of direct quotations may affect...

Re 1), the work I was intending to do (fleshing out what was then the criticism section) was done by another editor, and I don't believe there is any...

Retrieved 2024-07-18. ALT1: ... that the Idaho State Veterans Cemetery faced criticism in 2014 when it didn't allow a lesbian couple to be buried together? Source:...

understand why it is phrased and quoted, but I don't see how that changes my criticism. I could come up with an ALT, but I would prefer that you would as an...

promotion and while the reviews are largely positive, there is a bit of criticism to balance things out as well. The hooks are interesting and sourced to...

wanted to write a rebuttal... I found myself compelled to question all the criticism and to read the studies... I wrote to [my patients] and explained that...

interruption. notably, it was held in 2021, during the pandemic, which drew much criticism online. created by dying (talk). self-nominated at 23:11, 4 June 2023...

(UTC) ( Back to TM:TDYK Article history ) ... that whilst Pravda censored criticisms of the Soviet political system when reprinting the debates from the 1976...

issuing reports that were too technical and lacking in ideology-based criticisms? ALT 3: ... that prior to his better known textbook writing activities...

history ) ... that the 2012 political book Britannia Unchained attracted criticism after accusing British employees of being "among the worst idlers in the...

found to have bag marks on receipt. The Royal Mint responded to this criticism by saying that no indication had been given that the crowns were intended...

well-sourced, and has no issues in terms of neutrality or copyvio. The one criticism I have, which is not a bar to passing DYK, is that there are a lot of...

via Tandf Online. Townsend, Mark (2024-06-24). "UK 'tried to suppress criticism' of alleged UAE role in arming Sudan's RSF militia". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077...

be called 'Sewer Walk'"? Source: Moss, Michael (May 6, 1988). "Tide of Criticism Rises on River Walk". New York Newsday. ALT3: ... that New York City's...

18:36, 20 February 2014 (UTC) Thank you for the detailed and intricate criticism of the hook you requested BM. The simple solution is to remove the (pictured)...

that the term self-deportation was first popularized as a satirical criticism of California Proposition 187 in 1994? Created/expanded by BDD (talk)...

history ) ... that scientists publishing in Liebigs Annalen were subject to criticism and attacks by editor Justus von Liebig? Source: Partington, James Riddick...

see no neutrality or copyright concerns. I commend you for including criticism too. I love ALT1, but the original hook is hilarious. I would drop "two"...

the new Dutch coalition government." I'll likely add something like a "criticism" section or something. Of course, I may be wrong, which will make the...

did make it look as though the one influenced the other; that's a fair criticism. These are mentioned on page 226 of source #3. This is covered on page...

violence ... as an ethnicity Anti-Christian sentiment Christian universalism Criticism Jesus Cultural Christians Good and evil Great Apostasy Martyrs Miracle...

this a reference to some particular school of poetry writing or poetry criticism? Or just a reference to any poem that uses symbolism? Secondly, poems...

controversial legality at present), so if there is a moderate preponderance of criticism overall, that is not "UNDUE". Wnt (talk) 15:50, 8 February 2014 (UTC)...

best idea would be something like "... that the name Eoscorpius faced criticism for being applied to a scorpion with relatively modern features?" If you...

Jacel Kiram in the Philippines to support peace efforts in Sabah, drawing criticism from some local politicians? Source: "Uproar over photo of Anwar's daughter...

an Alt to make it clearer that he was one of a group that faced those criticisms (said to be led by Mints with Gorodestsky in a leading role). The charges...

okay to not want that. Also... you say you appreciate the constructive criticism but have kept the irrelevant photo in the article and you haven't fixed...

fault of the news article but I don't even understand if any substantive criticism was made other than "it'll make Dennis R. happy" and "anything invoking...

"citation needed" tag and a paragraph that lacks any citations under "Criticism". Yoninah (talk) 21:05, 9 January 2018 (UTC) @Yoninah:  Done CeeGee 06:40...

Belle (talk) 15:31, 9 June 2015 (UTC) ALT1: ... that in response to the criticism of Madonna's profound use of "bitch" on "Bitch I'm Madonna", she said...

Jehovah's Witness Latter Day Saint Swedenborgian Related topics Art Adherents Criticism Culture Ecumenism Liturgy Mission Other religions Persecution Prayer Sermon...

Fälschung" (beware falsification)." Personally, I don't agree with the criticism; the hook does not assert that all German conservatives agreed with this...

surrounding her. Eg. "In the film First Lady Imelda responds to some of the criticisms that were leveled against her while her husband was in power." Especially...

Distinctions Role in Western society Science and the Catholic Church See also: Criticism of the Catholic Church Anti-Catholicism Media Holy See Press Office Vatican...

interesting. The article prose is engaging and well written. My only criticism is that the use of inter alia in the hook seems entirely unnecessary,...

religions Judeo-Christian Pluralism Related topics Jews Zionism Israel Criticism Antisemitism Anti-Judaism Holocaust theology Music Jesus Muhammad Judaism...

Documentary hypothesis Synoptic problem NT textual categories Biblical criticism Historical Textual Source Form Redaction Canonical Interpretation Hermeneutics...

Intellectuals and Society (2010) See also Agnotology Critical theory Cultural criticism Cultural pessimism Ethics Historism Historicism Humanities Philosophy...

a U.S. congressional hearing about China after she refused to remove criticism of Trump from her testimony? Source: https://thehill...

when I searched (the link in the ref is broken...) and learned the BLM criticism was about a good deal more than just the appropriation of the name. My...

citations and also appears like a WP:LINKFARM. I hope this is constructive criticism. I am willing to complete the full DYK review with some changes to the...

says "The perfumes received primarily negative feedback and received criticism as a failed attempt to revive the group's career" but neither of these...

"yes". Ritchie333 (talk) (cont) 15:03, 14 July 2014 (UTC) This isn't a criticism of you, Ritchie, because you always show good judgment as I recall, but...

ldren-in-need-doctor-who-unleashed ALT1: ... that Doctor Who received criticism for retroactively removing a physical disability from Davros (pictured)...

August 2016 (UTC) Curse my crapping reading compression skills! Alright, criticism taken. Here's a new hook: ALT3: ... that Mark Barrott originally planned...

24 July 2018 (UTC) @Gatoclass: Well, ALT0 references the most common criticism, so there's [2] and [3] as English sources to back it up. The first one...

2019 (UTC) @GreenMeansGo: Sorry for the absence. I understand the egg criticism but the one problem with the hook revision is that it doesn't give a good...

should AFD it as an unnecessary fork, or withdraw your argument as a DYK criticism, since there is no reason to argue the article is not based on new content...

Hindu religion are the appropriate place to address controversies and criticisms. This article is well-focused on the text that is the subject of the article...

revival by region Balkans Gaza Strip Sudan United Kingdom Related topics Criticism Political aspects of Islam Political Islam Islam in South Asia North Africa...

v t e The Bible and history General studies Biblical criticism Biblical studies Biblical historiography Ancient Israel and Judah Quest for the historical...

13 July 2015 (UTC) @Ks03: - discussion here, but be prepared for the criticism! Mjroots (talk) 20:52, 14 July 2015 (UTC) Mjroots - Wow, didn't expect...

better idea of what needs to be fixed. But we can't fix anything if the criticism is vague.Zigzig20s (talk) 09:41, 15 July 2014 (UTC) OK, there is no longer...

ALT5, I think, is that it would publish a criticism as fact. I personally wouldn't mind, since the criticism is plainly absurd, but not everyone agrees...

your intentions here; I'm trying to protect you as a WP editor, from criticism. If there is vagueness, it's always worth naming the vague writer, to...

articles Creating controversial content Criticisms of society may be consistent with NPOV and reliability Criticism Describing points of view Don't "teach...

(2002) "Mojave Experiment" (2006) "I'm a PC" (2008) "Scroogled" (2012) Criticism Bundling of Microsoft Windows Clippy iLoo Internet Explorer Microsoft...

are listed? Or, if we have to list all 5, can we also include *some* criticism to make it more neutral overall? I'm just not comfortable with the section...

Foundations Fauji (Joint) Askari (Army) Bahria (Navy) Shaheen (Air Force) Criticism Establishment Gang of Four Bangladesh genocide Categories (Army • Air...

that these were RS. Nor did I search to see if there is any scholarly criticism of him that should be included. For all I know, his work was discredited...

hooks are forever being criticised for being dry and uninteresting - a criticism of Template:Did you know nominations/Gander Green Lane was that the proposed...

verbalising the very high profit made - and it is balanced by the negative criticism by Gill at the end. Spot checks for sources of copyvio and close paraphrasing...

Triangle K Union of Orthodox Synagogues Related Civil laws regarding kashrut Criticism of kashrut Kosher airline meal Kosher restaurant (list) Kosher style Kosher...

Utopian socialism Related topics Capitalism Communist society Criticism of capitalism Criticism of socialism Economic calculation problem Economic system...

representation of social and political mores" vs "they frequently voiced criticism of ruling regimes in the region and often presented a satirical depiction...

Poets Essayists Historians Travel writers Sufi writers Forms Novel Poetry Criticism and awards Literary theory Critics Literary prizes See also El Majdoub...

controversial critiques of Iggy Azalea in White Privilege II are actually criticisms of his own white privilege? ALT2: ... that many of the verses rapped by...

references. Tags have gone. To be a GA it would need some balance with a criticism section, but not necessary for DYK. The article just escapes advert as...

new to me. I can only suppose that in my quest for NPOV, I blunted the criticism from such folks as Jerry Lembcke too much, leading you to think I scanted...

light pollution measurements (which could reasonably be construed as a criticism of the program), the "reasons for concern" provides the context for why...

Woodrow Wilson Memorial CCISUA Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty Criticism Delivering as One Drug control treaties Expulsion from the United Nations...

Singhal Shirley M. Tilghman Hal Varian Rachel Whetstone Susan Wojcicki Criticism General Censorship DeGoogle FairSearch "Google's Ideological Echo Chamber"...

France has erroneously believed that she was the first driver. - The criticism of The Nostalgia Forum as a reference is not valid. It clearly states...

looking at the sources, I think the article misrepresents the nature of the criticism. People weren't criticizing the nudity so much as they were saying the...

and neo-Nazism? Reviewed: The book actually makes many more interesting criticisms but I wasn't sure of the best way to fit them into a DYK hook. It'd be...

Otherwise the sourcing seems fine, and the hook is sourced, so no big criticisms there, nothing worth holding this up for, IMO. But I was unable to verify...

"There are many ways of transforming a work, like using it for parody or criticism or summarizing it—or, as courts have repeatedly found, using it as the...

I've done this dozens of times. My reference to the redirect wasn't a criticism of your article, but a reassurance to other editors, since in your creation...

October 2016 (UTC) Well, as you know, I have come in for quite a bit of criticism recently over reviews and promotions, and BLPs are not my area of specialism...

be drawn, David Levy's criticisms here have at least been reasoned; this whining that nothing can even touch on outside criticism is mindlessly craven....

topics Ik Onkar Waheguru Panj Pyare Nirgun and Sargun Nanakshahi calendar Criticism Jathedar of Akal Takht War Sects Sikhism and other religions Sikhism and...

misunderstanding. editorEهեইдအ😎 10:17, 1 March 2016 (UTC) It was your criticism of referenced content, which was indeed factual. And it's "your", not...

persons Mentioned by name Characteristics I'jaz Inerrancy Related topics Criticism Attempted imitations Miniature Board Digital Quran and Sunnah Quranism...

Proposed acquisition of Warner Bros. Discovery by Paramount Skydance Criticism CBS News MTV List of films Paramount Pictures Miramax Republic Pictures...

many of its offers of help." [1] "the president has used international criticism to mobilise supporters, projecting himself as a patriot defending Brazil...

comedians face taboos regarding immodesty, impoliteness, and social criticism? ALT4: ... that the dangers of Canada's vast and sparsely populated climate...

11 March 2016 (UTC) I will admit I have to agree with DaltonCastle's criticism of the original hook. Not only for its vagueness, but also because this...

told lies? Source: https://www.enotes.com/topics/b-ryan-s-tanley-johnson/criticism/johnson-b-ryan-s-tanley-1933-1973 ALT1: ... that parts of the novel Travelling...

explanatory notes on protocol pages becoming extremely detailed. See also Criticism of Wikipedia § Excessive rule-making and Wikipedia:Content forking/Internal...

Anti-communist mass killings Communist terrorism Communist propaganda Criticism of communist states Mass killings under communist regimes Cambodian genocide...

Apostles (genre) Four Evangelists Additional Scriptures Studies Biblical and Quranic narratives Synod of Hippo Textual criticism Category Portal WikiProject...

why the church wasn't rebuilt... the sources don't say. For your other criticisms: The precise statement in the article is "In 1279 the priory's church...

the linked person previously. I’m fine with alt 1. I appreciate your criticism because I was able to find more sources. SL93 (talk) 22:24, 20 December...

not violate the neutrality or plagiarism guidelines for DYK. My only criticism would be that both the primary hook and ALT2 do not seem interesting to...

Supreme Court specifically. This shouldn't be really a hard task given that criticism of the Supreme Court is on the rise. Szmenderowiecki (talk) 09:32, 4 June...

for trying hard with the hook. We'll get there, but so far still some criticism, some very minor: I believe that the initial comma is correct but is in...

Kingdom law for example) allows for "non-commercial research or study, criticism or review"; something like this would certainly fall under one of those...

Settlement Body International Trade Centre Chronology of key events Issues Criticism Doha Development Round Singapore issues Quota Elimination Peace Clause...

Analysis Antisemitism Anti-Palestinianism Criticism Criticism of Hamas Criticism of Israel Israeli criticism of the occupation Media coverage Peace process...

Marion William Lane Craig Ali Akbar Rashad Alexander Pruss Related topics Criticism of religion Desacralization of knowledge Ethics in religion Exegesis History...

ALT1: ... that Ina Hartwig (pictured), who was responsible for literary criticism for the Frankfurter Rundschau, published a biography of Ingeborg Bachmann...

Marx Reading Political Post- Regulation school Subaltern Studies Value-criticism World-systems theory Other tendencies Austrian Centrist Marxism Black...

promotion, when I noticed several large quotations in the "Reception and criticism" section. Excessive quotations are not allowed per WP:NFC#Text, and I...

(1978) Why Beauty Matters (2009) Related Applied aesthetics Arts criticism Art criticism The arts and politics Aestheticization of politics Artistic freedom...

states that he "is" considered the apostle. So I do not understand your criticism. Could you give some examples of what you mean? Daniel the Monk (talk)...

South Street Seaport Studios The Linq Miscellaneous History Programs Criticism This Is SportsCenter ESPN Zone ESPN Wide World of Sports Complex ESPN...

above ALT2 ... that after the 2021 Myanmar coup, Maw Htun Aung posted criticism of the military junta on social media? per Reuters on August 2, 2021 Thoughts...

Inertial Upper Stage Payload Assist Module International Space Station Criticism Retirement Conroy Virtus Hail Columbia (1982 documentary) The Dream Is...

topics Socioeconomic development Progressive revelation Cosmology Symbols Criticism Homosexuality Gender Science Prophecies Statistics Orthography Category...

completed with history, nomination, selection, recipients, controversies and criticism section something along the lines of Rajiv Gandhi Khel Ratna & Tenzing...

East Syriac Armenian Byzantine Miscellaneous Antipopes Anti-Catholicism Criticism Deism/Pandeism Ecumenism Monasticism Relations with: Islam Judaism (Zionism)...

can/should be paraphrased. czar ⨹ 13:59, 13 May 2015 (UTC) - Too many criticisms in a 'pass' to feel comfortable 'passing'. If you could just tweak it...

opposite. The Reception section starts out oddly with the phrase "mixed criticism", which to me means he's been criticized by everyone with varying levels...

Sectarian Wealth Secularism and irreligion Agnosticism Antireligion Atheism Criticism Deconstruction Objectivism Secular humanism Secular religion Secular theology...

section to first cite that Twitch received criticism for policy updates and then cite exactly what that criticism is (unfair application of the policy updates...

Controversy: A Case History in the Hermeneutical Tension between Biblical Criticism and Christian Moral Debate". Religion and American Culture: A Journal...

launch the women-only game jam early in 2014 when it became the subject of criticism on social media after Quinn learned of the project." and should be rephrased...

meet either WP:NPOV or WP:UNDUE. The article is almost entirely about criticisms about the app, which seems undue weight in my opinion. At the very least...

#notyourshield originated within the 4chan's imageboard /v/ as a response to the criticism of misogyny during the GamerGate? NeoGaze (talk) 15:28, 26 November 2025...

predecessor game was finally announced, users flooded the comments with harsh criticism, saying things like, "Its only redeeming feature is its chubby cheeks...

enough. Well-sourced and copyvio-free. Neutral; I notice the relevant criticism is expertly woven into the text as it should be, which is indicative of...

not. Cambalachero (talk) 14:21, 7 May 2025 (UTC) I disagree with the criticism against ALT1, let me rephrase it to be more interesting: ALT3: ... that...

about jurisdiction regarding all future cases." This is a frustrating criticism because that's exactly what the Court was doing. It's like saying "ALT2...

Prose is a prose … (author, date) (style) (composition) (reception, films followed)     title. title. title. title.     Template documentationviewedithistorypurge...

Iwaszkiewicz wrote positively about..." and the sentence about Gruszecka's criticism would need some editing (I don't how Gruszecka thinks a 1897 novel would...

Frederick Henry Ambrose; Edward Miller (1894). A Plain Introduction to the Criticism of the New Testament. Vol. 1 (4th ed.). London: George Bell & Sons. p...

Artwork is a ... (sculpture / ceramic / glass object / jewellery / woodwork / paper art / origami / sand Art / ice sculpture / wallpainting / cave art...

important. "This created controversy..." "This led to criticism" - the controversy led to criticism? "...ChiCon, a fan was allegedly banned from the convention...

test. Real musicians will know that "blues nightmare" is actually not a criticism; it means there are great harmonic scrunches in there - musicians' music...

@Launchballer and Aafi: what am I supposed to address? If there is any specific criticism or suggestion for improvement, I'll gladly consider it, but 'can be made...

13 May 2017 (UTC) I appreciate your POV and have tried to address your criticism. Thanks for the copy editing. 7&6=thirteen (☎) 11:45, 13 May 2017 (UTC)...

nation's conscience," he said ("he" being Horton Davies, verifying his criticism of South African churches in 1961) "Church Role in S. Africa Outlined"...

(UTC) Ms. Davis appears to be beyond reproach. I haven't seen a word of criticism about her, so I personally have no problem accepting her first-hand account...

work at the Rawi Screenwriters Lab is not sourced. Also, only positive criticisms of Nowar's work are mentioned on the page. Are there any reviews that...

Jackson's message. Also, consider: However, it also faced increasing criticism from political figures who considered it excessively powerful and insufficiently...

historicity of Jesus Reliability of the Gospels Mythology Jesus myth theory Criticism Unknown years Relics Religious perspectives on Jesus Christian Jewish...

their style as much as possible, that they might enjoy the guessing and criticism as each novel appeared. This book was very successful in preserving its...

book cited in the Talattof reference 6, there is a section dealing with criticism of Avini - for example on page 182 it talks about Behnoud's accusations...

Cline (talk) 12:43, 6 December 2012 (UTC) I'm only offering constructive criticism. The hook is a line that comes straight from an advertisement -- that's...

Blake|lit}} Mythology {{William Blake|myth}} Art {{William Blake|art}} Criticism and scholarship {{William Blake|crit}} The template should not be placed...

False Infomercials Mobiles Modeling Radio Sex Slogans Testimonials TV Criticism of advertising Annoyance factor Censorship and mass media regulation Books...

racist” Added; it seems like they were arguing that the Castile incident criticism was UNDUE "the wider Wikipedia community failing to reach a consensus...

correct and courteous to point that out. But is is not acceptable to take criticism to a personal level. Thank you for completing the review, --Peter I. Vardy...

--Katolophyromai (talk) 20:15, 9 February 2018 (UTC) Okay, I will then retract my criticism on that point and take a look at the new source. Meanwhile, please add...

the American Broadcasting Company History of ESPN Assets Acquisitions Criticism Libraries Logo Headquarters Company officials Key Founders Walt Disney...

Ravidassia Women in Sikhism Sikhism and sexual orientation Idolatry in Sikhism Criticism Punjab History Punjabis Punjabi language (Gurmukhī) Sacred trees Takht...

Models Finnish models Karlsruhe model Zurich model Other topics Boarding Criticism of bus rapid transit Crush load Dwell time Hail and ride Land transport...

sourced. BlueMoonset (talk) 17:17, 31 August 2013 (UTC) Thank you for your criticism, I will need a bit of clarification though. Do you only object to this...

Lorie Logan (Dallas) Mary C. Daly (San Francisco) Related Central bank Criticism of the Federal Reserve Fed model Fedspeak Fed put Jackson Hole Economic...

hook here, though the subsequent French removal ties in well with the criticism of French colonialism. I've struck the original overlong hook and the...