The Ugly American (film)

The Ugly American
The Ugly American
	Theatrical release poster by Renato Fratini
Directed by	George Englund
Screenplay by	Stewart Stern
Based on	The Ugly American; by Eugene Burdick; William Lederer
Produced by	George Englund
Starring	Marlon Brando; Sandra Church; Eiji Okada; Pat Hingle; Judson Pratt; Reiko Sato; Arthur Hill;
Cinematography	Clifford Stine
Edited by	Ted J. Kent
Music by	Frank Skinner
Distributed by	Universal-International
Release date	April 2, 1963;
Running time	120 minutes
Country	United States
Language	English
Box office	$3,500,000

The Ugly American is a 1963 American adventure film directed by George Englund, written by Stewart Stern, and starring Marlon Brando, Sandra Church, Eiji Okada, Pat Hingle, Judson Pratt, Reiko Sato, and Arthur Hill. It is based on the 1958 novel The Ugly American by Eugene Burdick and William Lederer. The film was released on April 2, 1963, by Universal Pictures.^[2]^[3]^[4]

Plot

The setting is the present day in Sarkhan, a fictional Southest Asian country roiled by civil unrest and divided between the Communist North Sarkhan and South Sarkhan. Americans and Sarkhanese are building a "Freedom Road" in Sarkhan, which anti-American Sarkhanese view as an exercise in American imperialism of no value to the people. As the film begins, saboteurs murder a U.S. worker on the highway and send his truck plunging his truck down an embankment, making it look as if he were drunk, A local worker is killed. One of the saboteurs rails against the death and ascribes it to American imperialism.

In Washington, hearings are held on a new American ambassador to Sarkhan. The nominee is Harrison MacWhite, a journalist and World War II veteran who had become acquainted with Sarkhan during the war. At the hearing, Senator Brenner grills MacWhite about his qualifications, including his links to Deong, an old friend of MacWhite he had met during the war. Deong has become Sarkhan's most prominent revolutionary leader. Brenner reads an article quoting Deong sounding hostile and anti-American; MacWhite says the quote is old and taken out of context, and that he believes Deong is a man of honor.

When MacWhite and his wife arrive in Sarkhan, a mob of rebels swarm the airport and attack his car, even crashing a wooden board through the window close to his wife. The furious MacWhite asks why his staff didn't warn him about the threat, and threatens to fire them if they fail again.

That night, MacWhite is pleased to reunite with Deong at his home.They get drunk together and talk some politics, which leaves MacWhite disturbed. He drives around the city, thinking about it. Returning to Deong's home late that night, the men fight bitterly over politics, and MacWhite leaves believes Deong is a Communist.

MacWhite decides that the Freedom Road should rerouted to a more provocative location, close to the border with North Sarkhan. He convinces the Sarkhan government to go along with this. Its prime minister reluctantly agrees, on condition that the U.S. Seventh Fleet intervene if necessary.

MacWhite and his wife travel to the countryside where they encounters Homer and Emma Atkins, a benevolent American couple running charity operations benefitting the people. Homer tells him that the Freedom Road the Americans are helping build, is seen by many Sarkhanese as an imperialist project. He says the planned rerouting of the road is a bad idea, but MacWhite insists.

Deong secretly visits Communist leaders - Soviet, Chinese, North Sarkhanese - in a forest, saying he'll consider their offers of arms and other aid. He demands that they eschew violence.

Rebel cadres led by Deong sabotage the Freedom Road opening attended by Sarkhan's king and by MacWhite and his wife, causing a fiasco and casualties.

Foreign parachutists land in Sarkhan. The prime minister asks MacWhite for American military intervention, and he proves to MacWhite that there is a Communist plot to assassinate Deong after Deong has seized power. He says that Deong has been betrayed, that he is not a Communist but a "dupe." He says that he is willing to form a coalition government with Deong, who is holding a vigil demanding immediate ouster of the government.

MacWhite visits Deong and convinces him that the Communists plans to kill him. Deong is shot in front of MacWhite, and as he dies he tells a deputy to form a coalition government.

The Seventh Fleet intervene. MacWhite realizes he has misjudged Deong, was too simplistic and arrogant about his own beliefs, and had not credited Deong for having the same drive for independence that America's own founders did. He discusses some of this during a television address, and is about to discuss what would be good American policy and appeal to every American, but an "average American" TV viewer turns off the address in mid-speech.

Cast

Marlon Brando as Ambassador Harrison Carter MacWhite
Eiji Okada as Deong
Sandra Church as Marion MacWhite
Pat Hingle as Homer Atkins
Arthur Hill as Grainger
Jocelyn Brando as Emma Atkins
Kukrit Pramoj as Prime Minister of Sarkhan
Judson Pratt as Joe Bing
Reiko Sato as Rachani, Deong's Wife
George Shibata as Munsang
Judson Laire as Senator Brenner
Philip Ober as Ambassador Sears
Yee Tak Yip as Sawad, Deong's Assistant
Carl Benton Reid as Senator at Confirmation Hearing
Simon Scott as Johnson
Frances Helm as TadRed
James Yegi as Berg
John Daheim as Her (as John Day)
Leon Lontoc as Lee Pang
Bill Stout as Tyler, NBC Reporter
Stefan Schnabel as Andrei Krupitzyn

Production and screenplay

The film version of the novel was made in 1963 and starred Marlon Brando as Ambassador Harrison Carter MacWhite. Reiko Sato was cast as Rachani at the urging of Brando, who had dated her years prior.^[5]

The screenplay was written by Stewart Stern, and the film was produced and directed by George Englund. The film was shot mainly in Hollywood, with Thailand serving as the inspiration for the background sceneries. Parts of the film were also shot on locations in Bangkok, Thailand, including at Chulalongkorn University, one of the leading institutes of higher learning of the country.

Critical reaction

The Ugly American received mixed reviews and was completely overwhelmed by a number of more popular films that year.^[6] The film won no Golden Globes and was not nominated for an Oscar. It did poorly at the box office and was not among the year's top 25 grossing films of 1963.^[7]

The New York Times reported that Brando “moves through the whole picture with authority and intelligence,” and the New York Daily News said it was “one of Brando’s best performances.” But the negative view was reflected by the critic in Time who wrote that Brando “attempts an important voice but most of the time he sounds like a small boy in a bathtub imitating Winston Churchill” and called it a “lousy picture.”^[8]

Review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes reports that 80% of critics have given the film a positive review, with a rating average of 6.1/10.^[9]

Of twenty-three reviews examined by historian Jon Cowans, fourteen were positive, five negative, and four neutral or mixed. Brando had given interviews where he questioned American Cold War politics, and some reviewers agreed, but few of these reviews mentioned that the film was set in a country very much like Vietnam.

Only a few mentioned the point that, as The Dallas Morning News put it, one should “not assume that nationalism is inevitably anti-American,” and The New Republic was unusual in adding that “American blindness ... has driven many people particularly Asians, towards communism.” Some called Senator Brenner the real “ugly American” and objected to his McCarthyite tactics. The New York Post wrote that the film presented the dilemma that when Americans supported dictators, the Communists “make common revolutionary cause with the downtrodden.” Many East Coast reviews, however, objected to the film’s “oversimplification” of the issues.

The Washington Post wrote it was “nothing more than a western about the bad guys and the good guys.”^[8] TV Guide in a review says 'Although well-intentioned, THE UGLY AMERICAN simply isn't a very good film. Part of the problem is that producer-director George Englund, a friend of star Brando, isn't much of a director, and as a result the film is static and ponderous. Brando once again turns in an interesting performance, but as demonstrated in many of his films of this period, one good performance does not a good film make'.^[10]

Political impact

Kukrit Pramoj, a Thai politician and scholar, was hired as a cultural expert/advisor to the film and later played the role of Sarkhan's Prime Minister "Kwen Sai". Later on, in 1975, he, in fact, became the 13th Prime Minister of Thailand. Probably because of this, the word "Sarkhan" entered the Thai language as a nickname of Thailand itself, often with a slight self-deprecating or mocking tone.^[11] Much of the 'Sarkhanese' spoken in the film is actually Thai.

References

^ "Top Rental Films of 1963", Variety, 8 January 1964 p 37. Please note this figure is film rentals accruing to distributors, not gross takings.
^ Crowther, Bosley (1963-04-12). "Movie Review - The Ugly American - Screen:'The Ugly American' Opens:Marlon Brando Stars as the U.S. Diplomat". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 2016-03-25. Retrieved 2015-12-19.
^ "The Ugly American (1963) - Overview". TCM.com. Archived from the original on 2023-05-04. Retrieved 2015-12-19.
^ "The Ugly American". Afi.com. 1963-05-05. Retrieved 2015-12-19.
^ Clemens, Samuel (2022). Reiko Sato. Sequoia Press. p. 64. ISBN 9798885895675.
^ Stefan Kanfer (7 July 2011). Somebody: The Reckless Life and Remarkable Career of Marlon Brando. Faber & Faber. p. 187. ISBN 978-0-571-27878-7.
^ "Top Grossing Films of 1963". 2013-09-06. Retrieved 2015-05-18.
^ ^a ^b Cowans, Jon (2010). "A Deepening Disbelief: The American Movie Hero in Vietnam, 1958-1968". Journal of American-East Asian Relations. 17 (4): 324–351. doi:10.1163/187656111x564306., p. 333-339.
^ The Ugly American at Rotten Tomatoes
^ "The Ugly American Reviews". TV Guide. Archived from the original on 2023-04-24.
^ Rithdee, Kong (2015-01-31). "Don't blame Americans for bad acting". Bangkok Post. BangkokPost.com. Retrieved 2018-06-01.