To fill in the vacancy left by Cain vs dos Santos, Dana White confirmed on September 20, 2011 that Dan Henderson had re-signed with the UFC and would fight Maurício "Shogun" Rua for the main event.[7] White also declared that Shogun vs. Henderson would be a "No. 1 contender’s match" for the light heavyweight title. However, White clarified that Rashad Evans was still planned to get the title shot against the winner of Jon Jones vs Rampage Jackson, and that the winner of Shogun vs. Henderson would then get the second crack at the title.[8]
Johnny Eduardo was expected to face Michael McDonald at the event.[11] However, Eduardo was forced from the card with a shoulder injury on November 4[12] and replaced by promotional newcomer Alex Soto.[13]
During the official UFC 139 weigh ins, Shamar Bailey and Nick Pace failed to make the weight limit for their respective weight classes. Bailey came in 3 pounds over, while Pace came in six pounds over. Each fighter was fined 20 percent of their earnings and their bouts took at catchweights of 158 lb and 141 lb respectively.[15]
The event was well received by critics. The main event drew many accolades, including UFC President Dana White calling it "one of the top three best fights ever in MMA", later comparing the fight to the Thrilla in Manila.[16][17] The fight would later garner numerous Fight of the Year awards.[18][19][20] The fight was later included in the UFC Hall of Fame in 2018.[21]
Fight of the Night: Maurício Rua vs. Dan Henderson and Wanderlei Silva vs. Cung Le
Knockout of the Night: Michael McDonald
Submission of the Night: Urijah Faber
Reported payout
The following is the reported payout to the fighters as reported to the California State Athletic Commission. It does not include sponsor money or "locker room" bonuses often given by the UFC and also do not include the UFC's traditional "fight night" bonuses.[23]
Dan Henderson: $250,000 (no win bonus) def. Maurício Rua: $165,000
Wanderlei Silva: $200,000 (no win bonus) def. Cung Le: $350,000
Urijah Faber: $64,000 ($32,000 win bonus) def. Brian Bowles: $19,000
Martin Kampmann: $58,000 ($29,000 win bonus) def. Rick Story: $19,000
Stephan Bonnar: $68,000 ($34,000 win bonus) def. Kyle Kingsbury: $10,000
Ryan Bader: $48,000 ($24,000 win bonus) def. Jason Brilz: $13,000
Michael McDonald: $14,000 ($7,000 win bonus) def. Alex Soto: $6,000
Chris Weidman: $24,000 ($12,000 win bonus) def. Tom Lawlor: $12,000
Gleison Tibau: $54,000 ($27,000 win bonus) def. Rafael dos Anjos: $16,000
Miguel Torres: $60,000 ($30,000 win bonus) def. Nick Pace: $4,000 ^
Seth Baczynski: $16,000 ($8,000 win bonus) def. Matt Brown: $12,000
^ Shamar Bailey and Nick Pace were reportedly fined 20 percent of their purse for failing to make the required weight for their respective fights. The CSAC's initial report did not include information on the penalty.