Share to: share facebook share twitter share wa share telegram print page

Wax argument

The wax argument or the sheet of wax example is a thought experiment that René Descartes created in the second of his Meditations on First Philosophy. He devised it to analyze what properties are essential for bodies, show how uncertain our knowledge of the world is compared to our knowledge of our minds, and argue for rationalism.[1][2]

The thought experiment

Descartes first considers all the sensible properties of a sheet of wax such as its shape, texture, size, color, and smell. He then points out that all these properties change as the wax is moved closer to a fire. The only properties that necessarily remain are extension, changeability and movability:

Let us begin by considering the commonest matters, those which we believe to be the most distinctly comprehended, to wit, the bodies which we touch and see; not indeed bodies in general, for these general ideas are usually a little more confused, but let us consider one body in particular. Let us take, for example, this piece of wax: it has been taken quite freshly from the hive, and it has not yet lost the sweetness of the honey which it contains; it still retains somewhat of the odour of the flowers from which it has been culled; its colour, its figure, its size are apparent; it is hard, cold, easily handled, and if you strike it with the finger, it will emit a sound. Finally all the things which are requisite to cause us distinctly to recognise a body, are met with in it. But notice that while I speak and approach the fire what remained of the taste is exhaled, the smell evaporates, the colour alters, the figure is destroyed, the size increases, it becomes liquid, it heats, scarcely can one handle it, and when one strikes it, no sound is emitted. Does the same wax remain after this change? We must confess that it remains; none would judge otherwise. What then did I know so distinctly in this piece of wax? It could certainly be nothing of all that the senses brought to my notice, since all these things which fall under taste, smell, sight, touch, and hearing, are found to be changed, and yet the same wax remains.

Perhaps it was what I now think, viz. that this wax was not that sweetness of honey, nor that agreeable scent of flowers, nor that particular whiteness, nor that figure, nor that sound, but simply a body which a little while before appeared to me as perceptible under these forms, and which is now perceptible under others. But what, precisely, is it that I imagine when I form such conceptions? Let us attentively consider this, and, abstracting from all that does not belong to the wax, let us see what remains. Certainly nothing remains excepting a certain extended thing which is flexible and movable.

— René Descartes, 1911 edition of The Philosophical Works of Descartes (Cambridge University Press), translated by Elizabeth S. Haldane

These properties are, however, not directly perceived through the senses or imagination (the wax can be extended and moved in more ways than can be imagined). Instead, to grasp the essence of the wax, it must be done through pure reason:

We must then grant that I could not even understand through the imagination what this piece of wax is, and that it is my mind alone which perceives it.

— René Descartes, 1911 edition of The Philosophical Works of Descartes (Cambridge University Press), translated by Elizabeth S. Haldane

See also

References

Read other articles:

Amanda C. MillerAmanda C. Miller pada tahun 2015LahirAmanda Celine MillerJerman[1]Tempat tinggalAtlanta, Georgia, AS[1]AlmamaterUniversitas Maryland[1]PekerjaanPengisi suaraTahun aktif2009–sekarangOrang tuaRon Miller[2]Situs webamandacmiller.com Amanda Celine Miller adalah seorang pengisi suara Amerika Serikat dalam pengalihan bahasa Inggris untuk anime, animasi dan permainan video. Peran-peran besarnya meliputi Makoto Kino/Sailor Jupiter, dalam pengalihan …

Era atomica è un'espressione tipicamente usata per delineare il periodo della storia contemporanea che segue la scoperta della fissione nucleare di Otto Hahn nel 1938 e poi la detonazione della prima bomba nucleare su Hiroshima in Giappone nel 1945. Sebbene la tecnologia nucleare esistesse già prima di tale evento, il bombardamento atomico di Hiroshima e Nagasaki rappresentò il primo utilizzo pratico su vasta scala di tale tecnologia, introducendo profondi cambiamenti nel pensiero sociopoliti…

Love & GirlsSingel oleh Girls' GenerationSisi-BLingua FrancaDirilis19 Juni 2013 (2013-06-19)FormatCD single, digital downloadDirekam2013GenreJ-popLabelNayutawave Love & Girls adalah singel Jepang ketujuh oleh girlband Korea Selatan, Girls' Generation. Singel ini dirilis pada 19 Juni 2013. Latar belakang Diumumkan pada 5 April 2013, bahwa Girls' Generation akan merilis singel Jepang pertama pada tahun ini, Love & Girls, pada 29 Mei 2013.[1] Singel dirilis dalam dua versi;…

Andrew AdamsonAndrew Adamson pada peluncuran Our Nation's Children pada 29 November 2013PekerjaanProduser film, Film Director dan ScreenwriterTahun aktif1990 - Present Andrew Ralph Adamson (lahir 1 Desember 1966) merupakan seorang sutradara berkebangsaan Selandia Baru yang menjadi terkenal saat menyutradarai film utamanya seperti The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe. Dia dilahirkan di Auckland. Dia berkarier di dunia film sejak tahun 1971. Filmografi Tahun Judul Sebagai Worldwide Gross Pem…

47 Doughty Street berada di sebelah kiri, bersebelahan dengan Museum Charles Dickens, di tengah. Aggrey House adalah asrama yang didirikan di London pada tahun 1934 untuk tempat tinggal para mahasiswa Afrika dan mahasiswa keturunan Afrika. Namanya diambil dari James Emman Kwegyir Aggrey.[1] Terletak di 47 Doughty Street, rumah bertingkat dengan gaya arsitektur Georgia yang khas, dibangun berdasarkan rekomendasi dari komite Kantor Kolonial pada tahun 1930.[2] Ivor Cummings diangka…

This is a list of current and former cinemas in Hong Kong. Broadway Circuit PALACE ifc Former Broadway Olympian City cinema In addition to operating its own brand, Broadway Circuit also operates the B+, PALACE, Premiere Elements, MOViE MOViE and MY CINEMA chains. It previously run AMC-branded cinema in Pacific Place.[1] Broadway Cinematheque Broadway Hollywood, at Plaza Hollywood Broadway Kingswood Ginza, at Kingswood Ginza Broadway Kwai Fong, at Metroplaza Broadway Mongkok, on Sai Yeung…

Film Z adalah film-film beranggaran rendah yang memiliki kualitas lebih rendah daripada film B. Etimologi Penggunaan terawal dari istilah tersebut (sebagai film kelas-Z, dan tanpa arti penghinaan penuh yang biasanya dimaksudkan sekarang) sejauh ini terletak dalam sebuah ulasan surat kabar Januari 1965 oleh kritikus Kevin Thomas tentang The Tomb of Ligeia (1964), sebuah film American International Pictures yang disutradarai oleh Roger Corman.[1] Lihat pula Daftar film yang dianggap terbur…

Puteri Indonesia 1992Tanggal31 Oktober 1992[1]TempatJakarta Convention Center, Jakarta[1]Peserta26Finalis/Semifinalis5PemenangIndira Paramarini Sudiro DKI JakartaPersahabatanTantry Relatami Sulawesi Selatan← 19771994 →lbs Puteri Indonesia 1992 adalah kontes Puteri Indonesia yang pertama kali diselenggarakan oleh Mustika Ratu di bawah pimpinan Mooryati Soedibyo setelah sebelumnya diselenggarakan oleh pemerintah sejak tahun 1971. Kontes ini dimenangk…

العلاقات المكسيكية الناميبية المكسيك ناميبيا   المكسيك   ناميبيا تعديل مصدري - تعديل   العلاقات المكسيكية الناميبية هي العلاقات الثنائية التي تجمع بين المكسيك وناميبيا.[1][2][3][4][5] مقارنة بين البلدين هذه مقارنة عامة ومرجعية للدولتين: وجه المق…

English music hall comedian J. H. SteadSheet music cover, showing Stead jumping into the airBornJames Hurst Steadc. 1826Kingston upon Hull, YorkshireDied(1886-01-24)24 January 1886 (aged c. 60)LondonOccupation(s)Comedian, singerYears active1850s–1880s James Hurst Stead (c. 1826 – 24 January 1886) was an English music hall comedian, popular for several decades from the 1850s. Biography He was born in Kingston upon Hull, Yorkshire, and by the 1850s was performing in music halls ar…

Canal de Saint-Maurice Départ de l'ancien canal de Saint-Maurice Géographie Pays France Île-de-France Val-de-Marne Début Canal de Saint-Maur Fin Seine Caractéristiques Longueur 3,9 km Infrastructures Écluses Gravelle, Charenton Histoire Inauguration 1864 Fermeture 1950 Commanditaire l’État modifier  Le canal de Saint-Maurice était un canal du Val-de-Marne. La section de l'autoroute A4 passant par les communes de Saint-Maur des Fossés, Saint-Maurice et Charenton-le-Pont est …

American baseball player This biography of a living person needs additional citations for verification. Please help by adding reliable sources. Contentious material about living persons that is unsourced or poorly sourced must be removed immediately from the article and its talk page, especially if potentially libelous.Find sources: Mookie Wilson – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (June 2019) (Learn how and when to remove this message) Baseball…

Aker Stadion Informazioni generaliStato Norvegia UbicazioneReknes, Molde Inizio lavori1997 Inaugurazione1998 Costo212 000 000 corone ProprietarioMolde Fotballklubb ProgettoKjell Kosberg Informazioni tecnichePosti a sedere11 800 Classificazionecategoria 4 UEFA Mat. del terrenoErba Dim. del terreno105 × 68 m Uso e beneficiariCalcio Molde Mappa di localizzazione Modifica dati su Wikidata · ManualeCoordinate: 62°44′00.28″N 7°08′53.27″E / 62.7…

Francis Marion National ForestPalmetto TrailLocationSouth Carolina, United StatesNearest cityCharleston, SCCoordinates33°10′00″N 79°40′00″W / 33.166667°N 79.666667°W / 33.166667; -79.666667Area263,904 acres (1,067.98 km2)[1]Max. elevation80 ft. (24 m), 33.3912, -79.9054EstablishedJuly 10, 1936[2]Governing bodyU.S. Forest ServiceWebsiteFrancis Marion and Sumter National Forests The Francis Marion National Forest is located north o…

内華達州 美國联邦州State of Nevada 州旗州徽綽號:產銀之州、起戰之州地图中高亮部分为内華達州坐标:35°N-42°N, 114°W-120°W国家 美國建州前內華達领地加入聯邦1864年10月31日(第36个加入联邦)首府卡森城最大城市拉斯维加斯政府 • 州长(英语:List of Governors of {{{Name}}}]]) • 副州长(英语:List of lieutenant governors of {{{Name}}}]])喬·隆巴爾多(R斯塔夫…

American science fiction magazine (1963–1967) This article is about the science fiction magazine. For the science fiction anthology, see Worlds of Tomorrow. For the setting, see Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow. The first issue of Worlds of Tomorrow was cover-dated April 1963 Worlds of Tomorrow was an American science fiction magazine published from 1963 to 1967, at which point it was merged into If. The first issue appeared in April 1963.[1] The last issue was published in May 19…

Questa voce o sezione sull'argomento centri abitati della Germania non cita le fonti necessarie o quelle presenti sono insufficienti. Puoi migliorare questa voce aggiungendo citazioni da fonti attendibili secondo le linee guida sull'uso delle fonti. Wangen im Allgäucittà Wangen im Allgäu – VedutaVeduta panoramica di Wangen LocalizzazioneStato Germania Land Baden-Württemberg DistrettoTubinga CircondarioRavensburg TerritorioCoordinate47°41′09″N 9°50′03″E / &#x…

The flag of the KAU as devised by Jomo Kenyatta in 1951 Part of a series on the History of Kenya Overview Timeline of Kenya List of years in Kenya Pleistocene Koobi Fora Hominins Olorgesailie Aechulean hand axe culture Kariandusi prehistoric site Enkapune Ya Muto Nataruk Neolithic Lothagam North Monumental Cemetery Kalokol Pillar Site Elmenteitan Culture Cushitic expansion Eburran industry Hyrax Hill African Iron Age Sirikwa culture Bantu expansion Nilotic expansion Urewe culture Thimlich Ohinga…

American political party The rent is too damn high redirects here. For the book with that title, see Matt Yglesias. This article needs to be updated. Please help update this article to reflect recent events or newly available information. (December 2021) Rent Is Too Damn High Party LeaderJimmy McMillanChairmanJimmy McMillanSpokespersonCaprice AlvesFounded2005 (2005)HeadquartersFlatbush, Brooklyn, New York CityIdeologyPopulismSocial welfareAnti-taxAnti-high rentColors  PurpleSloganThe r…

Disambiguazione – Se stai cercando l'omonima provincia del Regno Lombardo-Veneto, vedi Provincia di Bergamo (Lombardo-Veneto). Questa voce o sezione sull'argomento Lombardia non cita le fonti necessarie o quelle presenti sono insufficienti. Puoi migliorare questa voce aggiungendo citazioni da fonti attendibili secondo le linee guida sull'uso delle fonti. Segui i suggerimenti del progetto di riferimento. Provincia di Bergamoprovincia Provincia di Bergamo – VedutaPalazzo della Provincia, …

Kembali kehalaman sebelumnya