Signet Society

The Signet Society of Harvard University was founded in 1870 by members of the class of 1871. The first president was Charles Joseph Bonaparte. It was, at first, dedicated to the production of literary work only, going so far as to exclude debate and even theatrical productions. According to The Harvard book^[1]

It seemed to the founders that there was room in the College world for another association that should devote itself more exclusively to literary work than is possible with large numbers. Accordingly, they confined the membership to a few, and required that new members shall be, so far as possible, "representative men," and that at least five should be in the first half of their class.

After a few years in quarters on university property, the Signet moved to an off-campus location at 46 Dunster Street.

The Signet Society's mission

The Signet's baroque cartouche contrasts with its neo-Federal façade.

The Signet celebrates most of the arts, including music, the visual arts, and theater. Members are active in most undergraduate publications. Many undergraduate Signet members are in other Harvard College artistic and literary organizations, including the Harvard Advocate, the Hasty Pudding Theatricals, the Harvard Crimson, the Harvard Lampoon, the Harvard Radcliffe Orchestra, and the Harvard Radcliffe Dramatic Club. It admits both men and women without prejudice, unlike final clubs. Membership dues are required, but are pro-rated by Harvard's financial aid calculations, allowing all members of the college community to be considered for membership. Harvard faculty and administrators have been and are Signet officers, associates, and members.

The opening remarks of the Signet's minutes state: "On Tuesday evening, November 1, 1870, a meeting was held at 10 Grays Hall preliminary to the organization of a senior society, which was to afford to a select number a pleasant means of intercourse with each other, not to be expected from the illiberal policy of the only society of reputation existing." This "illiberal policy" refers to the displeasure with which the founders of the Signet greeted the established Final Clubs. These first members formed the society's admissions criteria to transcend the social politics that they perceived as dominating in the Final Club system.

To distinguish the Signet from other exclusive organizations, the founding members stated in the original charter that members would be chosen according to "merit and accomplishment." Today, those membership criteria are still present in the club's constitution mandating that members "shall be chosen with regard to their intellectual, literary and artistic ability and achievements." While these criteria are central to the put-up process (admissions procedure), personal character is also considered.

Architecture

Signet Society, 46 Dunster Street. An 1820 Colonial residence, modified in 1880 into a Victorian clubhouse, then converted in 1902 by Cram, Goodhue & Ferguson into this Federalist structure.

Architectural historian Douglass Shand-Tucci includes an in-depth discussion of Signet's building in his history of Harvard's campus, relating the oddity that a firm known for its preeminence in Gothic Revival was employed to renovate an 1820s Colonial residence (converted in 1880 to a Victorian clubhouse) into a neo-Federal structure with baroque details. Regarding its distinctive features, Shand-Tucci writes:

It is in feeling wildly Baroque (of all things)—a welcome touch of flamboyance for what would otherwise have been a rather staid clubhouse for the Signet... the graphic quality of Cram & Goodhue's and LaRose's new frontispiece is actually rather reminiscent of book design (not to mention the Palladianism of several Tory Row mansions), and centers on a two story pedimented Ionic pavilion displaying the Signet arms.... The design concept- cavalier enough, but very successful—discloses another guise of history-making in Harvard architecture: to restore the house, not as it originally was, but in LaRose's words, as it "ought to have been." Thus the architectural solecism of the two orders of the porch—the Doric columns and Ionic pilasters—was retained.^[2]

Traditions

The emblem of the Signet was, at one time, "a signet-ring inclosing a nettle," the signet-ring symbolizing unity and the nettle symbolizing impartiality. The emblem which appears over the door of the Signet includes a beehive and bees, and a legend in Ancient Greek: μουσικήν ποίει και εργάζου -- "Create art, and live it." Another motto of the Society is attributed to Virgil: Sic vos non vobis Mellificatis apes -- "So do you bees make honey, not for yourselves." From this comes the Society's tradition of referring to its undergraduate members as "drones."

The Signet eschews initiation rituals common to Harvard's Final Clubs and the Lampoon in favor of an induction, during which each new member receives a red rose. The rose is to be kept, dried, and returned to the Signet Society upon the publication of the member's first substantial published work. The Signet maintains a library of these works, which were originally literary, but now include programs or other artifacts marking the performance of music, films, or displays of the visual artistry of members.

Dried roses hang on the walls of the Signet nearby the works that occasioned their return. Particularly noteworthy is T.S. Eliot's rose, which hangs along with his original letter of acceptance to the society.

Since 1910, the Signet has hosted an Annual Dinner honoring poets, authors, musicians, and social commentators. The Signet has a longstanding, reciprocal relationship with the Elizabethan Club, (or "The Lizzie") of Yale University. The two organizations sporadically hold a lawn croquet tournament, for which a handled and engraved silver pudding cup in a mahogany case serves as the trophy.

An alumni corporation administers the Signet's endowment, property, and staff. Since 2010, the Society has hosted Artists-in-Residence in a second-floor apartment.^[3]

Notable members

Following is a list of notable members of the Signet Society.^[4]

Academia

Derek Bok, Harvard President
James B. Conant, Harvard President, scholar, chemist
Charles W. Eliot, Harvard President, chemist, mathematician
Owen Gingerich, professor emeritus of astronomy and of the history of science at Harvard University and a senior astronomer emeritus at the Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory
Mason Hammond, Classics scholar
William James, philosopher, psychologist, and the first educator to offer a psychology course in the United States
Thomas Kuhn, philosopher and college professor
Abbott Lawrence Lowell, Harvard President, historian
Charles Eliot Norton, author, social critic, and Harvard professor
Neil Rudenstine, Harvard President
Arthur Schlesinger, Jr., historian
Andrew Weil, founder of the Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine at the University of Arizona College of Medicine

Entertainment

Andy Borowitz, writer, comedian, actor
Leonard Bernstein, composer and conductor
Amy Brenneman, actress
Nicholas Britell, film composer and producer
Tommy Lee Jones, actor
Rashida Jones, actress
John Lithgow, actor
Donal Logue, actor
James Murdoch, media owner
Conan O'Brien, talk show host
Natalie Portman, actress
Whit Stillman, writer-director
Tom Werner, producer, Red Sox co-owner
Alan "Scooter" Zackheim, reality show winner Beauty and the Geek

Literature

James Agee, novelist, screenwriter, poet, author
Conrad Aiken, author
John Ashbery, poet, writer
John Berendt, writer
Earl Derr Biggers, novelist and playwright
T. S. Eliot, poet, author
Robert Frost, poet
Donald Hall, poet
Seamus Heaney, poet
Norman Mailer, writer
Samuel Eliot Morison, Pulitzer Prize winning author, maritime historian, and retired Rear Admiral
George Plimpton, writer, journalist
George Santayana, philosopher, poet, novelist
Wallace Stevens, poet
John Updike, writer
John Hall Wheelock, poet

Journalism

Jill Abramson, executive editor of The New York Times
Adam Gopnik, writer for The New Yorker
Hendrick Hertzberg, senior editor of The New Yorker
Walter Isaacson, chair and CEO of CNN and the editor of Time
Joseph Lelyveld, executive editor of The New York Times
Frank Rich, essayist and liberal op-ed columnist with The New York Times
Reihan Salam, executive editor of National Review
Alessandra Stanley, co-founder of Air Mail
Andrew Sullivan, founder of the political blog The Daily Dish
Richard Tofel, former president of ProPublica
Fareed Zakaria, editor, author, commentator

Religion

Peter J. Gomes, preacher, theologian

Politics

Benazir Bhutto, late Prime Minister of Pakistan
Charles Joseph Bonaparte, United States cabinet member
Hamilton Fish II , Congressman
Mark Penn, pollster, author
Jay Rockefeller, U.S. Senator from West Virginia
Franklin D. Roosevelt, 32nd President of the United States
Theodore Roosevelt, 26th President of the United States
Chuck Schumer, U.S. Senator from New York
Caspar Weinberger, former Secretary of Defense
William Weld, former Massachusetts Governor

Fictional members

James "Toofer" Spurlock, fictional character on television show 30 Rock

Controversy

One of the Signet Society's "gravest mistakes" was their rejection of cellist Yo-Yo Ma while he was an undergraduate at Harvard.^[5]

References

Notes

^ "The Harvard book: a series of historical, biographical, and descriptive sketches". www.hcs.harvard.edu. 1875. Retrieved 2023-01-13.
^ (p.92, "The Campus Guide: Harvard University", Princeton Architectural Press ISBN 1-56898-280-1)
^ "The Signet Society - Ben Cosgrove". Archived from the original on 2013-12-03.
^ "The Signet Society - Signet Society Members". Archived from the original on 2009-11-06.
^ Conversations with Mark Hruby, Volume I, 2016. The Signet Society.

Sources

Signet Society Website
Documents relating to the Yale Elizabethan Club's organization and activities include correspondence, some written in Latin, with the Signet Society and are viewable through the online Yale Manuscripts and Archives Collection: [1]
Birnbach, Lisa The Official Preppy Handbook, mentions Signet