Share to: share facebook share twitter share wa share telegram print page

Rigour

Rigour (British English) or rigor (American English; see spelling differences) describes a condition of stiffness or strictness.[1] These constraints may be environmentally imposed, such as "the rigours of famine"; logically imposed, such as mathematical proofs which must maintain consistent answers; or socially imposed, such as the process of defining ethics and law.

Etymology

"Rigour" comes to English through old French (13th c., Modern French rigueur) meaning "stiffness", which itself is based on the Latin rigorem (nominative rigor) "numbness, stiffness, hardness, firmness; roughness, rudeness", from the verb rigere "to be stiff".[2] The noun was frequently used to describe a condition of strictness or stiffness, which arises from a situation or constraint either chosen or experienced passively. For example, the title of the book Theologia Moralis Inter Rigorem et Laxitatem Medi roughly translates as "mediating theological morality between rigour and laxness". The book details, for the clergy, situations in which they are obligated to follow church law exactly, and in which situations they can be more forgiving yet still considered moral.[3] Rigor mortis translates directly as the stiffness (rigor) of death (mortis), again describing a condition which arises from a certain constraint (death).

Intellectualism

Intellectual rigour is a process of thought which is consistent, does not contain self-contradiction, and takes into account the entire scope of available knowledge on the topic. It actively avoids logical fallacy. Furthermore, it requires a sceptical assessment of the available knowledge. If a topic or case is dealt with in a rigorous way, it typically means that it is dealt with in a comprehensive, thorough and complete way, leaving no room for inconsistencies.[4]

Scholarly method describes the different approaches or methods which may be taken to apply intellectual rigour on an institutional level to ensure the quality of information published. An example of intellectual rigour assisted by a methodical approach is the scientific method, in which a person will produce a hypothesis based on what they believe to be true, then construct experiments in order to prove that hypothesis wrong. This method, when followed correctly, helps to prevent against circular reasoning and other fallacies which frequently plague conclusions within academia. Other disciplines, such as philosophy and mathematics, employ their own structures to ensure intellectual rigour. Each method requires close attention to criteria for logical consistency, as well as to all relevant evidence and possible differences of interpretation. At an institutional level, peer review is used to validate intellectual rigour.

Honesty

Intellectual rigour is a subset of intellectual honesty—a practice of thought in which ones convictions are kept in proportion to valid evidence.[5] Intellectual honesty is an unbiased approach to the acquisition, analysis, and transmission of ideas. A person is being intellectually honest when he or she, knowing the truth, states that truth, regardless of outside social/environmental pressures. It is possible to doubt whether complete intellectual honesty exists—on the grounds that no one can entirely master his or her own presuppositions—without doubting that certain kinds of intellectual rigour are potentially available. The distinction certainly matters greatly in debate, if one wishes to say that an argument is flawed in its premises.

Politics and law

The setting for intellectual rigour does tend to assume a principled position from which to advance or argue. An opportunistic tendency to use any argument at hand is not very rigorous, although very common in politics, for example. Arguing one way one day, and another later, can be defended by casuistry, i.e. by saying the cases are different.

In the legal context, for practical purposes, the facts of cases do always differ. Case law can therefore be at odds with a principled approach; and intellectual rigour can seem to be defeated. This defines a judge's problem with uncodified law. Codified law poses a different problem, of interpretation and adaptation of definite principles without losing the point; here applying the letter of the law, with all due rigour, may on occasion seem to undermine the principled approach.

Mathematics

Mathematical rigour can apply to methods of mathematical proof and to methods of mathematical practice (thus relating to other interpretations of rigour).

Mathematical proof

Mathematical rigour is often cited as a kind of gold standard for mathematical proof. Its history traces back to Greek mathematics, especially to Euclid's Elements.[6]

Until the 19th century, Euclid's Elements was seen as extremely rigorous and profound, but in the late 19th century, Hilbert (among others) realized that the work left certain assumptions implicit—assumptions that could not be proved from Euclid's Axioms (e.g. two circles can intersect in a point, some point is within an angle, and figures can be superimposed on each other).[7] This was contrary to the idea of rigorous proof where all assumptions need to be stated and nothing can be left implicit. New foundations were developed using the axiomatic method to address this gap in rigour found in the Elements (e.g., Hilbert's axioms, Birkhoff's axioms, Tarski's axioms).

During the 19th century, the term "rigorous" began to be used to describe increasing levels of abstraction when dealing with calculus which eventually became known as mathematical analysis. The works of Cauchy added rigour to the older works of Euler and Gauss. The works of Riemann added rigour to the works of Cauchy. The works of Weierstrass added rigour to the works of Riemann, eventually culminating in the arithmetization of analysis. Starting in the 1870s, the term gradually came to be associated with Cantorian set theory.

Mathematical rigour can be modelled as amenability to algorithmic proof checking. Indeed, with the aid of computers, it is possible to check some proofs mechanically.[8] Formal rigour is the introduction of high degrees of completeness by means of a formal language where such proofs can be codified using set theories such as ZFC (see automated theorem proving).

Published mathematical arguments have to conform to a standard of rigour, but are written in a mixture of symbolic and natural language. In this sense, written mathematical discourse is a prototype of formal proof. Often, a written proof is accepted as rigorous although it might not be formalised as yet. The reason often cited by mathematicians for writing informally is that completely formal proofs tend to be longer and more unwieldy, thereby obscuring the line of argument. An argument that appears obvious to human intuition may in fact require fairly long formal derivations from the axioms. A particularly well-known example is how in Principia Mathematica, Whitehead and Russell have to expend a number of lines of rather opaque effort in order to establish that, indeed, it is sensical to say: "1+1=2". In short, comprehensibility is favoured over formality in written discourse.

Still, advocates of automated theorem provers may argue that the formalisation of proof does improve the mathematical rigour by disclosing gaps or flaws in informal written discourse. When the correctness of a proof is disputed, formalisation is a way to settle such a dispute as it helps to reduce misinterpretations or ambiguity.

Physics

The role of mathematical rigour in relation to physics is twofold:

  1. First, there is the general question, sometimes called Wigner's Puzzle,[9] "how it is that mathematics, quite generally, is applicable to nature?" Some scientists believe that its record of successful application to nature justifies the study of mathematical physics.
  2. Second, there is the question regarding the role and status of mathematically rigorous results and relations.[clarification needed] This question is particularly vexing in relation to quantum field theory, where computations often produce infinite values for which a variety of non-rigorous work-arounds have been devised.

Both aspects of mathematical rigour in physics have attracted considerable attention in philosophy of science (see, for example, ref.[10] and ref.[11] and the works quoted therein).

Education

Rigour in the classroom is a hotly debated topic amongst educators. Even the semantic meaning of the word is contested.

Generally speaking, classroom rigour consists of multi-faceted, challenging instruction and correct placement of the student. Students excelling in formal operational thought tend to excel in classes for gifted students.[citation needed] Students who have not reached that final stage of cognitive development, according to developmental psychologist Jean Piaget, can build upon those skills with the help of a properly trained teacher.

Rigour in the classroom is commonly called "rigorous instruction". It is instruction that requires students to construct meaning for themselves, impose structure on information, integrate individual skills into processes, operate within but at the outer edge of their abilities, and apply what they learn in more than one context and to unpredictable situations.[12]

See also

References

  1. ^ "Definition of RIGOR". www.merriam-webster.com. Retrieved 2019-10-20.
  2. ^ "Rigor – Etymology". etymonline.com. 2001–2014. Retrieved 2015-01-10.
  3. ^ Amort, Eusebio. Theologia Moralis Inter Rigorem et Laxitatem Medi.
  4. ^ "GA1: Intellectual Rigour - Southern Cross University". www.scu.edu.au. Retrieved 2019-10-20.
  5. ^ Wiener, N. (1985). Intellectual honesty and the contemporary scientist. In P. Masani (Ed.), Norbert Wiener: Collected works and commentary (pp. 725–729).
  6. ^ Pierpont, James (January 1928). "Mathematical rigor, past and present". Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society. 34 (1): 23–53. doi:10.1090/S0002-9904-1928-04507-X. ISSN 0002-9904. S2CID 120096416.
  7. ^ For more, see Euclidean geometry—19th century and non-Euclidean geometry.
  8. ^ Hardware memory errors are caused by high-energy radiation from outer space, and can generally be expected to affect one bit of data per month, per gigabyte of DRAM.[1].
  9. ^ This refers to the 1960 paper The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences by Eugene Wigner.
  10. ^ Davey, Kevin, ”Is Mathematical Rigor Necessary in Physics?”, The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 54 (2003) 439–463.
  11. ^ Gelfert, Axel, ”Mathematical Rigor in Physics: Putting Exact Results in Their Place”, Philosophy of Science, 72 (2005) 723–738.
  12. ^ Jackson, R. (2011). How to Plan Rigorous Instruction. Alexandria, VA.: ASCD.

Read other articles:

Untuk film tahun 2008, lihat The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (film). The Curious Case of Benjamin Button PengarangF. Scott FitzgeraldNegaraA.S.BahasaBahasa InggrisGenreCerita pendekTanggal terbit1921Jenis mediaPrint (Majalah) The Curious Case of Benjamin Button merupakan cerita pendek oleh F. Scott Fitzgerald dan diterbitkan di Majalah Colliers pada tahun 1921. Ia yang diantalogikan dalam bukunya, Tales of the Jazz Age, yang diterbitkan sebagai The Curious Case of Benjamin Button a…

9975 TakimotokosoOrbit 9975 Takimotokoso (biru), planet-planet (merah) dan Matahari (hitam). Orbit planet terluar yang terlihat adalah Yupiter.PenemuanDitemukan olehK. Endate and K. WatanabeTanggal penemuan12 September 1993PenamaanPenamaan alternatif1993 RZ1, 1978 WF15Ciri-ciri orbitEpos 27 October 2007Aphelion2,8140368 SAPerihelion2,110202 SASumbu semimayor2,4621194 SAEksentrisitas0,1429327Periode orbit1411,1139887 hAnomali rata-rata270,51412°Inklinasi1,04678°Bujur node menaik247,20…

Académie Royale d'ArchitectureMedali peringatan, 1671Latin: Regia architectonices academia instituta MDCLXXIPendiri Louis XIV dari Prancis Jean-Baptiste Colbert Didirikan1671HeadFrançois Blondel (1671)Anggota 8 saat didirikan 33 pada 1793 LokasiParis, PrancisDibubarkan1793, 1816 Académie Royale d'Architecture (bahasa Prancis: [akademi ʁwajal d‿aʁʃitɛktyʁ]; Inggris: Royal Academy of Architecture) adalah perhimpunan terpelajar Prancis yang didirikan pada 1671. Perhimpunan ini me…

Agonist drug having partial efficacy at a receptor Relationship between percentage activity and concentration of full agonists and partial agonists In pharmacology, partial agonists are drugs that bind to and activate a given receptor, but have only partial efficacy at the receptor relative to a full agonist. They may also be considered ligands which display both agonistic and antagonistic effects—when both a full agonist and partial agonist are present, the partial agonist actually acts as a …

Hospital in London, EnglandDulwich Community HospitalDulwich Community HospitalShown in SouthwarkGeographyLocationEast Dulwich Grove, Southwark SE22 8PT, London, EnglandCoordinates51°27′31″N 0°04′53″W / 51.4585°N 0.0813°W / 51.4585; -0.0813OrganisationCare systemNHS EnglandServicesEmergency departmentNoHistoryOpened1887; 137 years ago (1887)Closed2020LinksListsHospitals in England Dulwich Community Hospital was a hospital located in Dulwich, …

ولادة النجوم وسط بين نجمي غيمة جزيئية كرة بوك سديم مظلم جرم نجمي فتي نجم أولي نجم تي الثور نجم قبل النسق الأساسي هيربيغ أي/ نجم بي سديم شمسي أصناف الأجرام الفلكية جرم هيربج هارو المفاهيم النظرية دالة الكتلة الأولية كتلة جينس آلية كلفن هلمهولتز فرضية السديم هجرة الكواكب هذا ا…

Kementerian Kehutanan Republik IndonesiaGambaran umumDibentuk2005; 19 tahun lalu (2005)Dibubarkan2014; 10 tahun lalu (2014) Nomenklatur penggantiKementerian Lingkungan Hidup dan Kehutanan Republik Indonesia Kementerian Kehutanan (dahulu Departemen Kehutanan, disingkat Dephut) adalah kementerian yang pernah ada dalam Pemerintah Indonesia yang membidangi urusan kehutanan dan perkebunan. Kementerian Kehutanan dipimpin oleh seorang Menteri Kehutanan (Menhut) yang sejak tanggal 22 Oktober 2…

Oakland, California began a program of designating the city's historic landmarks and properties starting in 1973.[1] Many of the properties have also received recognition at the federal level by inclusion on the National Register of Historic Places or by designation as National Historic Landmarks.[2] Color markings (highest noted listing) Map all coordinates using OpenStreetMap Download coordinates as: KML GPX (all coordinates) GPX (primary coordinates) GPX (secondary coordinates…

Voce principale: Rovigo Calcio. Rovigo CalcioStagione 2006-2007Sport calcio Squadra Rovigo Allenatore Carmine Parlato Presidente Francesco Scerra Serie C26º posto nel girone B Coppa Italia Serie CPrimo turno Maggiori presenzeCampionato: Rizzi (32) Miglior marcatoreCampionato: Gasparello (13) StadioStadio Francesco Gabrielli 1949-1950 2007-2008 Si invita a seguire il modello di voce Questa pagina raccoglie le informazioni riguardanti il Rovigo Calcio nelle competizioni ufficiali della stagi…

Danish artist (1804–1880) Constantin HansenConstantin Hansen Illustreret Tidende, 4. april 1880Born(1804-11-03)3 November 1804Rome, Papal StatesDied29 March 1880(1880-03-29) (aged 75)Copenhagen, DenmarkNationalityDanishEducationRoyal Danish Academy of Fine ArtsKnown forPaintingNotable workA Group of Danish Artists in Rome (1837) The Danish Constituent Assembly (1861-1865)MovementDanish Golden Age, Romanticism The Danish Constituent Assembly (1861-1865) A Group of Danish Artists in Ro…

This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) This article needs to be updated. Please help update this article to reflect recent events or newly available information. (September 2022) This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Bay Fe…

ロバート・デ・ニーロRobert De Niro 2011年のデ・ニーロ生年月日 (1943-08-17) 1943年8月17日(80歳)出生地 アメリカ合衆国・ニューヨーク州ニューヨーク市身長 177 cm職業 俳優、映画監督、映画プロデューサージャンル 映画、テレビドラマ活動期間 1963年 -配偶者 ダイアン・アボット(1976年 - 1988年)グレイス・ハイタワー(1997年 - )主な作品 『ミーン・ストリート』(1973年)『…

Sexual entertainment venue Strip club in Munich, Germany A strip club is a venue where strippers provide adult entertainment, predominantly in the form of striptease or other erotic dances. Strip clubs typically adopt a nightclub or bar style, and can also adopt a theatre or cabaret-style. American-style strip clubs began to appear outside North America after World War II, arriving in Asia in the late 1980s and Europe in 1978,[1] where they competed against the local English and French s…

Syrian philosopher, sociologist and Arab nationalist (1910–1989) Aflak redirects here. For the village, see Aflak, Yüreğir. For the insurance company, see Aflac. Michel Aflaqميشيل عفلقMichel Aflaq in 1963Secretary General of the National Command of the Iraq-based Ba'ath PartyIn office8 February 1968 – 23 June 1989DeputyShibli al-AysamiPreceded byPosition establishedSucceeded bySaddam HusseinSecretary General of the National Command of the Arab Socialist Ba'ath PartyIn off…

Questa voce sull'argomento centri abitati dell'Ohio è solo un abbozzo. Contribuisci a migliorarla secondo le convenzioni di Wikipedia. Segui i suggerimenti del progetto di riferimento. Parmacity(EN) Parma, Ohio Parma – VedutaMuseo-Fattoria Stearns LocalizzazioneStato Stati Uniti Stato federato Ohio ConteaCuyahoga AmministrazioneSindacoTimothy J. DeGeeter (D) TerritorioCoordinate41°23′31″N 81°43′43″W / 41.391944°N 81.728611°W41.391944; -81.728611…

Russian neo-Nazi In this name that follows Eastern Slavic naming customs, the patronymic is Yurievich and the family name is Milchakov. Alexey MilchakovNative nameАлексей Юрьевич МильчаковNickname(s)Serb, FritzBorn (1991-04-30) April 30, 1991 (age 33)Leningrad, Russian SFSR, Soviet UnionAllegiance Luhansk People's Republic (2014–2015) Russia (2015–present)Service/branch Russian Airborne Troops Army of the South-East (2014) ENOT Corp[1] Wagner GroupUnit…

Roman goddess of liberty This article is about the Roman goddess. For other uses, see Libertas (disambiguation). LibertasGoddess of libertyLibertas with her attributes, on an aureus of TrajanSymbolPileus, rod (vindicta or festuca)EquivalentsGreek equivalentEleutheria Denarius (42 BC) issued by Cassius Longinus and Lentulus Spinther, depicting the crowned head of Libertas, with a sacrificial jug and lituus on the reverse Libertas (Latin for 'liberty' or 'freedom', pronounced [liːˈbɛrt̪aː…

Pour les articles homonymes, voir Courtier (homonymie). Si ce bandeau n'est plus pertinent, retirez-le. Cliquez ici pour en savoir plus. Cet article ne cite pas suffisamment ses sources (mars 2015). Si vous disposez d'ouvrages ou d'articles de référence ou si vous connaissez des sites web de qualité traitant du thème abordé ici, merci de compléter l'article en donnant les références utiles à sa vérifiabilité et en les liant à la section « Notes et références ». En prati…

约翰·迪芬贝克John George Diefenbaker加拿大总理任期1957年6月21日—1963年4月22日前任路易·圣洛朗继任萊斯特·皮尔逊 个人资料出生(1895-10-18)1895年10月18日 加拿大安大略省诺伊施塔特(英语:Neustadt, Ontario)逝世1979年8月16日(1979歲—08—16)(83歲) 加拿大安大略省渥太華墓地加拿大萨斯喀彻温省萨斯卡通迪芬貝克加拿大中心(英语:Diefenbaker Canada Centre)政党加拿大進步保守黨…

Association football team in Spain Football clubCastellónFull nameClub Deportivo Castellón, S.A.D.Nickname(s)Orelluts Albinegres AlbinegrosFounded20 July 1922; 101 years ago (1922-07-20)GroundNou Estadi CastàliaCapacity15,500[1]OwnerHaralabos VoulgarisPresidentHaralabos VoulgarisHead coachDick SchreuderLeaguePrimera Federación – Group 22022–23Primera Federación – Group 2, 3rd of 20WebsiteClub website Home colours Away colours Club Deportivo Castellón, S.A.D.…

Kembali kehalaman sebelumnya