In Singapore, a town council (TC) is an entity formed by at least one elected Member of Parliament (MP) and appointed residents who are responsible for the day-to-day operations in managing the common property of the Housing and Development Board (HDB) residential flats and commercial property within the town.[1] The sizes and structure of a town council can be changed due to political electoral changes. It is often considered a very limited form of local government that are strictly limited to estate management, and where their members have no separation of powers from the national government. As of November 2020, there are 17 town councils operating in Singapore.[1]
Singapore's rapid development in the 19th century meant that there was an increasing demand for the management of municipal matters beyond the ad-hoc management of such matters by the British colonial government. In 1887, the Municipal Commission of Singapore was established that split the administration of the town area and the rural districts, and also had its own source of municipal funds that were separate from government revenue. The Commission initially comprised an appointed full-time salaried president, and five elected members. It supported numerous improvement projects over the next few decades such as establishing a fire brigade, enlarging reservoirs, and providing street lighting. In 1913, the commission was reorganised and elections were abolished, although they were reintroduced in 1949 to encourage greater civic participation.[2] Three elections were held for the commission from 1949 to 1950 before it was renamed in 1951.[3]
In 1951, the Municipal Commission was renamed the City Council when Singapore officially attained city status in the British Commonwealth.[4] The Municipal Building, from which the Commission operated, was also renamed City Hall.[5]
The Municipal Building, where the Municipal Commission operated, was renamed City Hall in 1951.
From 1951 to 1958, four full elections and one by-election were held for the City Council.[3]
Absorption of City Council into Government
By 1959, there was a widespread perception that the City Council was inefficient and corrupt. For example, it was reported by The Straits Times that an advertising agent had to bribe his way to get his licenses on time.[6] The People's Action Party (PAP) campaigned on the promise that if they were to win the general election on 30 May that they would reorganise the "present unwieldy, inefficient, expensive and wasteful system of government". First on the list of priorities was the absorption of the parallel administrations of the City Council and Rural Board into the central government.[7]: 87, [87]
When the PAP won, then-Minister for National Development Ong Eng Guan signed an order taking over the functions of the City Council and centralising these municipal functions under the Government.[8] The water, electricity and gas functions stayed with the City Council until 1963, when it was absorbed into the Public Utilities Board (PUB).[9]
Pilot Town Council programmes (1986–1988)
Although the PAP campaigned in the early years that local government functions were inefficient for a small city-state like Singapore,[7]: 87, [87] the party changed its mind a few decades later. It decided in 1986 to decentralise some municipal functions because it wanted ostensibly to increase resident participation in estate management. As a result, three town councils were set up in Ang Mo Kio as a pilot programme to manage the estate.[10]
Town Councils Bill and Act (1988)
The three pilot town councils were deemed to be highly successful and led to the introduction of the Town Councils Bill in Parliament in May 1988.[11]Goh Chok Tong, who would eventually become Prime Minister in 1990, argued in Parliament that town councils not only provided for greater resident participation, but also would act as "political stabilisers".[12]: 379, [379] He cited the fact that in other democracies, e.g. Britain, there were inherent factors that resulted in greater political stability, such as long-term allegiances of constituencies to a certain political party. But in Singapore,
... it is the PAP which provides the political stability. There is no other party at present which can effectively govern Singapore. But this political stability can be threatened by sudden temporary swings in national mood. If there are such swings, the PAP can be out of power. If that happens, political instability will result because no alternative leadership has emerged which can effectively govern Singapore.[12]: 384, [384]
Goh also noted in the same speech in Parliament that voters were confident that after decades of uninterrupted PAP rule, that even if they elected opposition candidates to Parliament that they would still have a competent PAP government managing their constituencies, which would result in a "free-rider" problem:
For example, some voters who want a PAP government also want to see some opposition MPs. They may vote for an opposition candidate and depend on the PAP to look after their constituency because they expect other constituencies to return PAP candidates in sufficient numbers to form the government.[12]: 385, [385]
Chiam See Tong, then-MP for Potong Pasir and one of only two non-PAP MPs at that time, spoke at length rejecting the bill. Chiam argued that the role of an MP was to give direction to a nation, and not to manage municipal matters:[13]: 413, [413]
A party is elected because of its policy. The people may want the party to represent them so that the nation can move in a particular direction. The PAP first came into power on a socialist platform. People of Singapore voted them in because they thought that was good for Singapore and so they went on a socialist principle, up to lately, of course. Some people may want to vote people like Margaret Thatcher, free enterprise, the capitalist line. You vote her in. So that is the purpose of voting Members of Parliament and a particular party. But you do not vote a Town Councillor to change the direction or have a national policy in regard whether to foreign policy or to national policies on education or defence, or how you should have a relationship with your neighbours. These are not the work of town councillors. These are the work of Members of Parliament. So there is a distinct different role.[13]: 414, [414]
He also noted that most MPs did not stay in the same constituency, let alone the same housing estate, of their residents, and would therefore not add much value to the residents in such matters. He proposed that Town Councils should be made non-political, but was rebutted by Lee Hsien Loong that MPs should care for their constituents as much as they cared about lawmaking:
If any MP stands in the next election and says, "Please elect me. I will pay no attention to municipal matters. You go and find some non-political Town Councillor on your own to manage that and you have it out with HDB should anything happen", I do not think he is going to be elected. I do not think the Member for Potong Pasir will put that in the SDP manifesto. Will he? Perhaps not.[13]: 415, [415]
Ultimately, PAP's supermajority in Parliament allowed it to pass the bill into law without further consultation.[12]: 445, [445]
Formation
Within 30 days of winning an election, an MP will have to form a town council that consists of at least six members, but not more than 30 members.[14] The town council is led by a chairman who must be an elected MP, who can then appoint non-elected MPs to the town council as well. At least two-thirds of the appointed members must be residents living in the town to ensure good representation.[14]
List of town councils
As of 30 July 2020, there are 17 town councils in Singapore.
Aljuined–Hougang Town Council
Ang Mo Kio Town Council
Bishan–Toa Payoh Town Council
Chua Chu Kang Town Council
East Coast Town Council
Holland–Bukit Panjang Town Council
Jalan Besar Town Council
Jurong–Clementi Town Council
Marine Parade Town Council
Marsiling–Yew Tee Town Council
Nee Soon Town Council
Pasir Ris–Punggol Town Council
Sembawang Town Council
Sengkang Town Council
Tampines Town Council
Tanjong Pagar Town Council
West Coast Town Council
Functions
Town councils are an extremely limited form of local government which generally covers the maintenance and repair of common property in the HDB estates (not private property). These include but are not necessarily limited to cleaning of common areas in the HDB estates, lift maintenance, and some landscaping works, such as grass cutting.[15] Unlike local government, however, town councils are not directly elected and are in fact led by Members of Parliament (MPs) who are elected through general elections. This means that the town council role is really an extension of the MPs' responsibility, and not a separate office.
Apart from common property in the HDB estates, town council may also be required to manage or maintain other property as requested by the HDB or the government on an ad-hoc basis. With the approval of the Minister for National Development, the town council can also opt to carry out the work of any public authority or association if there is mutual agreement to do so.[16]
Powers
The Town Councils Act provides a town council with powers that enable it to maintain existing common property facilities, and also to establish new facilities, subject to the approval of the HDB where required. It can also maintain other property that is not common property if it is given permission from the Minister for National Development. It also has the power to set service and conservancy charges for the upkeep of the town.[17]
By-laws
Under the Town Councils Act, a town council may make by-laws as part of its estate management role.[16] As of 28 November 2019, there are 51 pieces of by-law legislation published in the Singapore Statutes.[18] The by-laws generally cover three main areas: (1) the rules governing the use of common spaces and open areas in the estate; (2) conservancy and service charges to be paid to the Town Council; and (3) the penalties for not paying those charges.
Funding
The funding sources of town councils are largely dominated by the government, even though the service and conservancy charges are collected from residents and commercial operators of the town.
Funding Sources
Apart from the service and conservancy charges (S&CC) that are paid by the residents and commercial operators of the town, a town council is also able to tap on numerous grants that the government provides.
S&CC Operating Grant
The S&CC operating grant is given by the Ministry of National Development (MND) to support the town council with their operating needs. The grant is disbursed annually,[1] and is allocated based on the number and type of HDB flats in the town. Smaller HDB flats are given a bigger grant than larger ones. No grant is given for 5-room flats.[19]
Goods & Services Tax (GST) Subvention
The GST Subvention is disbursed to the town council every quarter[1] and has been used to offset the increase in GST on the S&CC costs for residents at least since December 2002, when then-Minister for Finance Lee Hsien Loong announced an increase in GST from 3% to 4%.[20]
The Lift Enhancement Programme is a S$450m programme that was announced in September 2016,[21] in view that the funds maintained by all the town councils (estimated at S$1b in 2016) would not be sufficient for lift upgrading works in the housing estates, which was estimated at S$3b over the next 20 years. As a result of this programme, a new fund—the Lift Replacement Fund—was required to be set up by all town councils to contribute at least 14% of their income into. Under this programme, the HDB would co-fund up to 90% of the town councils' costs to retrofit older lifts with safety features and enhancements.
Announced in 2017, the Lift Maintenance Grant is disbursed annually and provides a S$600 grant per lift in every town to the town council to alleviate the higher costs of lift-related servicing and maintenance.[1]
Lift Replacement Fund Matching Grant
Also announced in 2017, the Lift Replacement Fund Matching Grant matches 50% of a town council's contribution to the Lift Replacement Fund and is disbursed quarterly.[1]
Community Improvement Projects Committee (CIPC) Funding
Town councils can also apply to the Community Improvement Projects Committee (CIPC) through the Citizens' Consultative Committees (CCC) of their towns for funding support for "improvement projects in HDB estates for the benefit of local residents".[22] This funding source is not explicitly stated on the MND website, but was revealed after a query by Pritam Singh, MP for Aljunied GRC, in 2015.[22] As of November 2019, the CIPC is made up of PAP MPs and losing PAP candidates from the most recent general election.[23]
Funds
Town councils are required to allocate their monies into three distinct funds:[1]
Operating Fund: For short-term, routine expenses;
Sinking Fund: For long-term, non-lift cyclical expenses; and
Lift Replacement Fund: For long-term, lift-related cyclical works.
Accountability
Town councils have to comply with legislation in the Town Councils Act. Some things that are considered offences include poor corporate governance procedures (e.g. not keeping a register of conflict of interests), not complying with notices from the HDB or any official direction given by the Minister for National Development, misuse of monies from funds that are managed by the town council, and failure to submit audited reports or statements.[14]
In addition, the Town Councils Act also allows for the delegation of powers by the town council to "any employee thereof or any agent"[14]: s32(2) to exercise or perform any function, power or duty.
Controversies
Action Information Management Pte Ltd (AIM)
In December 2012, Aljunied–Hougang Town Council was scored the lowest banding for S&CC arrears management.[24]Sylvia Lim, chairwoman of the town council, blamed the poor results on Action Information Management Pte Ltd (AIM), a vendor that provided computer systems for town council management. She claimed that the town council was "acutely aware" of the possibility that AIM, as a long-standing IT vendor for PAP town councils, could choose to withdraw from their contractual obligations at short notice. Because of this, the town council had to put in effort to create a new IT system,[25] which compromised their level of service. Chandra Das, AIM chairman, produced correspondence between the company and the town council that suggested otherwise—AIM in fact readily agreed to two extensions to the contract that was supposed to end on 1 August 2011.[25] This point is later corroborated again in the judgment of Aljunied–Hougang Town Council and another v Lim Swee Lian Sylvia and others and another suit.[26]
The structure of AIM and AIM's purchase of Town Council Management System
The complaint by Sylvia Lim on AIM led to an exchange between her and Teo Ho Pin. During one of those exchanges it was revealed that AIM was in fact backed by the PAP.[27] It was owned by three former PAP MPs—Chandra Das, Chew Heng Ching and Lau Ping Sum. AIM was also discovered to be a company with just S$2 (the minimum) in paid-up capital, and put into question how such a company would be considered strong enough to sell a sophisticated piece of software to.[28] Yet, AIM managed to bid successfully for the Town Council Management System (TCMS) owned by 14 town councils, for S$140,000, in 2010. This was done through an open tender where AIM was the only bidder.[28]
There was sufficient public interest in the matter for Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong to order an investigation into the transactions of AIM in January 2013. The scope of the investigation would also cover "observations on the nature of TCs and how they are run, with a view to improving the current framework".[29] The Ministry of National Development published the report in May 2013, and it was also debated in Parliament.[30] The ministry's review team concluded in the report that not only did the PAP town councils comply with the open tender process under the Town Councils Act, there was no "pecuniary or direct interest" on the part of any of the town council members on AIM.[29]
Aljunied–Hougang-Punggol East Town Council
Aftermath of the AIM investigation
In May 2013, the MND report on AIM and town councils was debated in Parliament.[30]Khaw Boon Wan, then-Minister for National Development, expressed during the ministerial statement that there were concerns on how Aljunied–Hougang Town Council (AHTC) waived the requirement for open tender and awarded a multi-million dollar contract to FM Solutions and Services Pte Ltd (FMSS), a company that was formed just days after the general election. Khaw mentioned several times during the ministerial statement that FMSS was formed and owned by a group of people loyal to the Workers' Party, and that awarding a contract without open tender seemed inappropriate.[30]
Attorney-General v Aljunied-Hougang–Punggol East Town Council
About a year later, in February 2014, AHTC submitted its audited financial statements for the financial year ending 31 March 2013. Its auditor, Foo Kon Tan Grant Thornton LLP, prepared an auditor's report containing 13 grounds of qualification. The auditor-general subsequently audited AHTC's financial statements and released a final report in February 2015, which the Ministry of National Development used as its basis to sue AHTC, mainly to force AHTC to appoint independent accountants to review their statements and ensure they complied with the town council rules.[31]: 22 The case was later dismissed in the High Court.
Criticisms
The town council model has been subject to criticism because it unnecessarily politicises what would have been a non-political function. Mak Yuen Teen, a professor at the National University of Singapore, suggested depoliticising the town council so that MPs can focus on "serving the residents in more impactful ways and on issues of national importance".[32] He rejected the idea that town councils made MPs more accountable for the running of estates and said,
"What were MPs doing before there were town councils in 1989?" Didn't they have political accountability then?[32]
Pakis AjiKecamatanNegara IndonesiaProvinsiJawa TengahKabupatenJeparaPopulasi • Total60,019 jiwa (2.015)[1] jiwaKode Kemendagri33.20.15 Kode BPS3320091 Luas61 km²Desa/kelurahan8 Gua Sakti Plajan Museum Gong Perdamaian Pakis Aji (Jawa: ꦥꦏꦶꦱ꧀ꦄꦗꦶ) adalah sebuah kecamatan di Kabupaten Jepara, Provinsi Jawa Tengah, Indonesia. Kecamatan ini merupakan hasil pemekaran dari kecamatan Mlonggo sesuai peraturan daerah kabupaten Jepara Nomor 17 tahun 2007 tentang …
Arthur RimbaudLahirJean Nicolas Arthur Rimbaud(1854-10-20)20 Oktober 1854Charleville-Mézières,PrancisMeninggal10 November 1891(1891-11-10) (umur 37)Marseille, PrancisMakamCharleville-Mézières Cimetière, Charleville-Mézières, PrancisPekerjaanSastrawan dan penyairPendidikan Pension Rossat (1862) College de Charleville (1865) Aliran sastraSimbolismePasanganPaul VerlaineTanda tangan Jean Nicolas Arthur Rimbaud (IPA: [aʀ'tyʀ ʀɛ̃'bo]) (20 Oktober 1854 – 10 No…
Édison Méndez Informasi pribadiNama lengkap Édison Vicente Méndez MéndezTanggal lahir 16 Maret 1979 (umur 44)Tempat lahir Ibarra, EkuadorTinggi 1,75 m (5 ft 9 in)[1]Posisi bermain GelandangInformasi klubKlub saat ini Santa FeKarier junior1996–2001 Deportivo QuitoKarier senior*Tahun Tim Tampil (Gol)1997–2002 Deportivo Quito 192 (18)2002–2003 El Nacional 34 (3)2004 Irapuato 16 (5)2004 Santos Laguna 14 (2)2005–2007 LDU Quito 60 (6)2006–2007 → PSV (pinjam…
Balimau di Pekanbaru Balimau adalah tradisi mandi menggunakan jeruk nipis yang berkembang di kalangan masyarakat Minangkabau dan biasanya dilakukan pada kawasan tertentu yang memiliki aliran sungai dan tempat pemandian.[1] Diwariskan secara turun temurun, tradisi ini dipercaya telah berlangsung selama berabad-abad.[2]Kawasan Lubuk Minturun populer dalam tradisi balimau di Padang Latar belakang dari balimau adalah membersihkan diri secara lahir dan batin sebelum memasuki bulan Ram…
Artikel ini sebatang kara, artinya tidak ada artikel lain yang memiliki pranala balik ke halaman ini.Bantulah menambah pranala ke artikel ini dari artikel yang berhubungan atau coba peralatan pencari pranala.Tag ini diberikan pada Desember 2023. Karyono H. Informasi pribadiLahir(1929-05-31)31 Mei 1929Meninggal6 Agustus 1989(1989-08-06) (umur 60)KebangsaanIndonesiaKarier militerPihak IndonesiaDinas/cabang TNI Angkatan DaratPangkat Kolonel TNISatuanCorps Angkutan Militer (CAM)Sunting kot…
Artikel ini sebatang kara, artinya tidak ada artikel lain yang memiliki pranala balik ke halaman ini.Bantulah menambah pranala ke artikel ini dari artikel yang berhubungan atau coba peralatan pencari pranala.Tag ini diberikan pada Januari 2023. Inspektur Hopkins, yang bernama lengkap Stanley Hopkins, adalah seorang detektif fiksi yang bekerja untuk Scotland Yard rekaan Sir Arthur Conan Doyle dalam kisah petualangan Sherlock Holmes. Hopkins, seperti termaktub dalam kisah Peter si Hitam, adalah or…
A Girl Like Me:The Gwen Araujo StoryPoster resmiSutradaraAgnieszka HollandProduserFran RosatiDitulis olehShelley EvansPemeranJ.D. PardoMercedes RuehlPenata musikJan A.P. KaczmarekSinematograferDavid FrazeePenyuntingMichael John BatemanDistributorLifetime TelevisionTanggal rilis19 Juni 2006Durasi96 menitNegara Amerika SerikatBahasaInggrisIMDbInformasi di IMDbSitus webhttp://lifetimetv.com/movies/originals/agirllikeme.php A Girl Like Me: The Gwen Araujo Story adalah film tahun 2006 yang…
Jerrold Reinach ZachariasLahir23 Januari 1905Jacksonville, FloridaMeninggal16 Juli 1986(1986-07-16) (umur 81)KebangsaanAmerikaAlmamaterColumbia UniversityPenghargaanOersted Medal (1961)Karier ilmiahBidangFisikaInstitusiMassachusetts Institute of TechnologyDisertasiDependensi temperatur modulus Young untuk nikel (1934)Pembimbing doktoralShirley Leon QuimbyMahasiswa doktoralJohn G. King, Rainer Weiss Jerrold Reinach Zacharias (23 Januari 1905 – 16 Juli 1986) adalah seoran…
Mary MaraudersUniversityUniversity of MaryConferenceNorthern Sun Intercollegiate ConferenceNCAADivision IIAthletic directorCooper JonesLocationBismarck, North DakotaVarsity teams17Football stadiumMDU Resources BowlBasketball arenaMcDowell Activity CenterBaseball stadiumBismarck Municipal BallparkSoccer stadiumMDU Resources BowlMascotMaximusNicknameMaraudersColorsBlue, white, and orange[1] Websitewww.goumary.com The Marauders are the athletic te…
Resolusi 1015Dewan Keamanan PBBKepolisian perbatasan SerbiaTanggal15 September 1995Sidang no.3.578KodeS/RES/1015 (Dokumen)TopikBekas YugoslaviaRingkasan hasil15 mendukungTidak ada menentangTidak ada abstainHasilDiadopsiKomposisi Dewan KeamananAnggota tetap Tiongkok Prancis Rusia Britania Raya Amerika SerikatAnggota tidak tetap Argentina Botswana Republik Ceko Jerman Honduras Indonesia Italia Nigeria Oman Rwanda …
Lambang Allier Untuk kotamadya, silakan lihat Allier, Hautes-Pyrénées Untuk teolog, silakan lihat Raoul Allier Allier (Occitan: Alèir) ialah sebuah departemen di Prancis selatan-tengah yang dinamai menurut Sungai Allier. Sejarah Allier ialah salah satu dari 83 departemen asli yang diciptakan selama Revolusi Prancis pada 4 Maret 1790. Diciptakan dari bagian bekas provinsi Auvergne dan Bourbonnais. Pada 1940, pemerintahan Marsekal Philippe Pétain memilih kota Vichy sebagai ibu kotanya. Geograf…
Orbit Geostasioner Orbit geostasioner atau orbit geopegun (Inggris: geostationary orbitcode: en is deprecated ) adalah orbit geosinkron yang berada tepat di atas ekuator Bumi (garis lintang 0°), dengan eksentrisitas orbital sama dengan nol. Dari permukaan Bumi, objek yang berada di orbit geostasioner akan tampak diam (tidak bergerak) di angkasa karena perioda orbit objek tersebut mengelilingi Bumi sama dengan perioda rotasi Bumi. Orbit ini sangat diminati oleh operator-operator satelit buatan (…
The SpoilersCuplikan filmSutradaraLambert HillyerProduserJesse D. HamptonDitulis olehElliott J. ClawsonBerdasarkanThe Spoilers olehRex BeachPemeranMilton SillsAnna Q. NilssonNoah Beery Sr.SinematograferJohn StumarDwight WarrenPerusahaanproduksiJesse D. Hampton ProductionsDistributorGoldwyn PicturesTanggal rilis 05 Agustus 1923 (1923-08-05) Durasi80 menitNegaraAmerika SerikatBahasaBisu (intertitel Inggris) The Spoilers adalah sebuah film drama bisu Amerika Serikat tahun 1923 garapan Lam…
Sarajevocomune(BS, HR, SR) Sarajevo/Сарајево Sarajevo – VedutaVeduta della città da est LocalizzazioneStato Bosnia ed Erzegovina EntitàFederazione di Bosnia ed Erzegovina Cantone Sarajevo AmministrazioneSindacoBenjamina Karić (SDP) TerritorioCoordinate43°51′23″N 18°24′47″E / 43.856389°N 18.413056°E43.856389; 18.413056 (Sarajevo)Coordinate: 43°51′23″N 18°24′47″E / 43.856389°N 18.413056°E43.856389; 18.41…
العلاقات البوليفية المولدوفية بوليفيا مولدوفا بوليفيا مولدوفا تعديل مصدري - تعديل العلاقات البوليفية المولدوفية هي العلاقات الثنائية التي تجمع بين بوليفيا ومولدوفا.[1][2][3][4][5] مقارنة بين البلدين هذه مقارنة عامة ومرجعية للدولتين: وجه ال…
His EminenceJean-Pierre KutwaCardinalArchbishop of AbidjanCardinal Kutwa.ArchdioceseAbidjanSeeAbidjanAppointed2 May 2006Installed18 June 2006PredecessorBernard AgréOther post(s)Cardinal-Priest of Santa Emerenziana a Tor FiorenzaOrdersOrdination11 July 1971by Bernard YagoConsecration16 September 2001by Bernard AgréCreated cardinal22 February 2014by Pope FrancisRankCardinal-PriestPersonal detailsBorn (1945-12-22) 22 December 1945 (age 78)Blockhauss, Ivory CoastNationalityIvorianDe…
MBTA Commuter Rail line Fitchburg LineAn outbound train arriving at South Acton station in 2022OverviewOwnerMassachusetts Bay Transportation AuthorityLocaleGreater BostonTerminiWachusettNorth StationStations17ServiceTypeCommuter railSystemMBTA Commuter RailTrain number(s)400–433 (weekday)1400-1415 (Saturday)2400-2415 (Sunday)Operator(s)Keolis North AmericaDaily ridership4,829 (October 2022)[1]TechnicalLine length54 miles (87 km)[2]CharacterCommuter rail lineTrack gauge4…
Untuk daftar orang yang pernah menjabat sebagai Utusan Tetap RI untuk PBB di Jenewa, lihat Daftar Utusan Tetap Indonesia untuk Perserikatan Bangsa-Bangsa, Organisasi Perdagangan Dunia, dan Organisasi Internasional Lainnya di Jenewa. Utusan Tetap Republik Indonesia untuk Perserikatan Bangsa-Bangsa di New YorkLambang Kementerian Luar Negeri Republik IndonesiaPetahanaArrmanatha Christiawan Nasirsejak 25 Oktober 2021Kementerian Luar NegeriPerutusan Tetap Republik Indonesia untuk Perserikatan Ba…