Critic James H. Pickering described the novel as rejecting the more established histories of the New York/Canada border war during the Revolution.[1] In part the novel represents Cooper's own knowledge of the regional oral history and affiliation with soldiers who had experienced the war.[1]
Critical reception
In his 1968 review of the novel, critic James H. Pickering called the novel one of "Cooper's more successful efforts".[1]
Williams, Jr., Kennedy (1978). George A. Test (ed.). "Cooper's Use of American History". State University of New York College at Oneonta and Cooperstown, New York: 15–25 – via James Fenimore Cooper Society. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)